HELP! The great Debate 370z vs. G37

dudafunk · 12-11-2009, 08:28 AM

I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price.

I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me:

- External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it.
- Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins
- When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins
- When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24

Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

TipsZ · 12-11-2009, 08:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dudafunk

I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price.

I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me:

- External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it. AGREED

- Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins AGREED

- When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins FAIL

- When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24

AGREED

Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

370Zsteve · 12-11-2009, 08:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dudafunk

I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price.

I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me:

- External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it.
- Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins
- When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins
- When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24

Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

Agree with everything except the mid-life crisis. What, I can't drive this beautiful car because I'm 55? WTF? I'm gonna leave all this FUN to a bunch of Generation-XXXX n00bs?

geez jk don't flame don't hate I love you all.

sinceday1 · 12-11-2009, 09:02 AM

I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book! What's wrong in someone wanting to drive a sports car when they're not in Teens, 20s,or even 30s? Maybe circumstances prohibited them to owning one. Maybe they simply love sports cars in general.. I'm 25. So no, my defence is not from experienced knowledge but I can say it isn't biased.

ANYWAYS to OP.
like everyone else said. If you have things to carry, get G, if not Z.
Both are amazing cars and I contemplated the exact same. (But up here in Canada, we do not have "Base" Z.)
Styling on Z is definitely much nicer than G IMO stock v stock but i think modified G looks as nice

TamZ · 12-23-2009, 01:40 AM

[QUOTE=sinceday1;317352]I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book!

I just finished a Developmental Psychology class in Nursing and we learned that a "mid-life crisis" is a MYTH. It was on a test.

lol... They also claim that "Empty Nest Syndrome" is also a MYTH. I'm more likely to suffer from the latter than the former. My 370Z isn't a mid-life crisis since I've had a 240Z, 280Z, 300ZX..I just love me some Z's

Edited to say: I did test drive the G37 coupe and the G37 convertible...But the Z won.

Slynky · 12-23-2009, 02:21 PM

[QUOTE=TamZ;338515]

Quote:

Originally Posted by sinceday1

I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book!

I just finished a Developmental Psychology class in Nursing and we learned that a "mid-life crisis" is a MYTH. It was on a test.

lol... They also claim that "Empty Nest Syndrome" is also a MYTH. I'm more likely to suffer from the latter than the former. My 370Z isn't a mid-life crisis since I've had a 240Z, 280Z, 300ZX..I just love me some Z's

Edited to say: I did test drive the G37 coupe and the G37 convertible...But the Z won.

Because if that's you in the avie, then you're not old enough for the former...

TamZ · 12-27-2009, 09:51 PM

[QUOTE=Slynky;339087]

Quote:

Originally Posted by TamZ

Because if that's you in the avie, then you're not old enough for the former...

Well I'm almost 40, so that is getting close! My oldest will be leaving the nest in about 4 years

Slynky · 12-23-2009, 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sinceday1

I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book! What's wrong in someone wanting to drive a sports car when they're not in Teens, 20s,or even 30s? Maybe circumstances prohibited them to owning one. Maybe they simply love sports cars in general.. I'm 25. So no, my defence is not from experienced knowledge but I can say it isn't biased.

ANYWAYS to OP.
like everyone else said. If you have things to carry, get G, if not Z.
Both are amazing cars and I contemplated the exact same. (But up here in Canada, we do not have "Base" Z.)
Styling on Z is definitely much nicer than G IMO stock v stock but i think modified G looks as nice

I'm nearing 60 and I've just liked hot/stylish cars all my life. Any affordable 2-seater (well, except maybe not a Miata...

).

I think they need the G at this stage of their marriage if they're only going to have a single vehicle. If they will have w vehicles, then I'd give more weight to the 2-seater.

Modshack · 12-23-2009, 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slynky

I'm nearing 60 and I've just liked hot/stylish cars all my life. Any affordable 2-seater (well, except maybe not a Miata...

).

I think they need the G at this stage of their marriage if they're only going to have a single vehicle. If they will have w vehicles, then I'd give more weight to the 2-seater.

Yeah, I'm there too.....You pick your cars to support your current stage in life. There are just times when a Minvan or 4 seater are just plain necessary. I have the Z, My wife has an Element, though she'd rather see herself in a Miata... I can see the need for 3 cars in the future, to help her with her image needs, and to maintain the practicality of the current rides... Usually 3 cars for the two of us is the magic formula. I've had 3 Miata's in the past...I can see a fourth to round out the stable....You guys can laugh all you want, but they are awesome drivers..

OldGuy · 12-28-2009, 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Modshack

Yeah, I'm there too.....You pick your cars to support your current stage in life. There are just times when a Minvan or 4 seater are just plain necessary. I have the Z, My wife has an Element, though she'd rather see herself in a Miata... I can see the need for 3 cars in the future, to help her with her image needs, and to maintain the practicality of the current rides... Usually 3 cars for the two of us is the magic formula. I've had 3 Miata's in the past...I can see a fourth to round out the stable....You guys can laugh all you want, but they are awesome drivers..

My other sports car is my M edition Miata I bought new in 1996 and will keep until my last day. I've put virtually every available aftermarket item on it and it is a true showpiece and future collector's car with only 35,000 mi. Although, like two of your kids, it and the Z have very different personalities, I love them both and will keep them both the rest of my years.

lrgoldberg02 · 12-30-2009, 09:19 PM

That's a totally sweet car. Interestingly, the other sports car I was cross-shopping against the Z was a new MX-5 Miata. I love that car - Definitely a pure driver's car in every sense of the word, despite what others may ignorantly think.

Post some pics of the Miata!

Quote:

Originally Posted by OldGuy

My other sports car is my M edition Miata I bought new in 1996 and will keep until my last day. I've put virtually every available aftermarket item on it and it is a true showpiece and future collector's car with only 35,000 mi. Although, like two of your kids, it and the Z have very different personalities, I love them both and will keep them both the rest of my years.

ban25 · 12-23-2009, 10:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Slynky

I'm nearing 60 and I've just liked hot/stylish cars all my life. Any affordable 2-seater (well, except maybe not a Miata...

).

I think they need the G at this stage of their marriage if they're only going to have a single vehicle. If they will have w vehicles, then I'd give more weight to the 2-seater.

Don't knock the Miata. I've owned a 1st-gen and it's an awesome ride. Brilliant handling at any price-point...

In fact, I'd take a hard-top MX-5 over a Z4 for half the price!

oo7mech · 12-11-2009, 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dudafunk

I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price.

I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me:

- External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it.
- Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins
- When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins
- When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24

Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

Hmm!! Nice ideas there. I am 25. We already have a 4 door sedan. We plan on having kids in 5 years when its time for a new car/suv later.
Luxury later... i like that!

MindFusion FX · 04-23-2010, 10:59 AM

i'm in the same boat...370z or g37s...im 24 as well so im thinking Z is gonna be it..i dont need luxury yet..and i have an suv as well incase i need extra seating.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dudafunk

I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price.

I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me:

- External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it.
- Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins
- When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins
- When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24

Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

oo7mech · 04-23-2010, 12:57 PM

What makes it even harder, if you put both cars right next to each other.
or maybe for you, it could make it easier.
Pictures of both

12-23-2009, 01:40 AM	#5 (permalink)
TamZ Enthusiast Member Join Date: Sep 2009 Location: So Cal Posts: 433 Drives: 2011 Mercedes GL 350 Rep Power: 17	[QUOTE=sinceday1;317352]I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book! I just finished a Developmental Psychology class in Nursing and we learned that a "mid-life crisis" is a MYTH. It was on a test. lol... They also claim that "Empty Nest Syndrome" is also a MYTH. I'm more likely to suffer from the latter than the former. My 370Z isn't a mid-life crisis since I've had a 240Z, 280Z, 300ZX..I just love me some Z's Edited to say: I did test drive the G37 coupe and the G37 convertible...But the Z won. __________________ Tammy Last edited by TamZ; 12-23-2009 at 01:42 AM.

04-23-2010, 12:57 PM	#15 (permalink)
oo7mech Enthusiast Member Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: Allen TX Posts: 328 Drives: White 370z Sport 7AT Rep Power: 17	What makes it even harder, if you put both cars right next to each other. or maybe for you, it could make it easier. Pictures of both __________________ PW Sport 370Z 7spd AT\|\|Stock Intake (shopping)\|\|Stock exhaust (shopping)\|\|Berk HFC\|\|Stock Headlights\|\|19"inch Ray Wheels Click and Jiggle Action Crossfit = No Quitters

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Great 370Z Review by TD tv in Australia 6-21-09	AK370Z	Nissan 370Z Photos / Spyshots / Video / Media Gallery	6	07-10-2009 09:50 AM
In a debate about rims...	rreign	Wheels & Tires	19	04-30-2009 07:12 AM
Great 370Z Color Scheme	SoCal 370Z	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	0	03-13-2009 10:35 AM
Great 370z site!	hollygl2009	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	2	03-12-2009 09:14 PM
370 debate on Camaro board	frost	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	132	01-25-2009 03:52 AM

12-11-2009, 08:28 AM	#1 (permalink)
dudafunk Enthusiast Member Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: Long Island, NY Posts: 421 Drives: '09 370z Base Red AT Rep Power: 17	I went thru the SAME Exact dilemma. New Z vs. old G for the same price. I decided to not go for the G, these were my conclusions, of course very personal to me: - External looks, Z wins. Wife will surely look sexy in it. - Keeping my old 4 seater so '2 seater being inconvenient for trips to the city' eliminated, Z wins - When I get older, I would go for an even more luxurious car than the G. Plenty out there. I'm a fan of great interiors (incidently I was the one who started the wood trim in the Z thread..LOL! because I was going thru the exact same problem of the Z not being luxurious from the inside).. Z wins - When I get older, no offense to anyone, it'd be nice to not be associated with a mid life crisis. Z wins at age 24 Z now, luxury car later. Hope that helps.

12-11-2009, 09:02 AM	#4 (permalink)
sinceday1 Track Member Join Date: Oct 2009 Location: Canada Posts: 514 Drives: 09 Nissan 370Z M6 Rep Power: 18	I'll have to agree with 370zsteve on that one. I dont understand what really constitutes as a 'mid life crisis' and whether it really exists! it's an urban myth in my book! What's wrong in someone wanting to drive a sports car when they're not in Teens, 20s,or even 30s? Maybe circumstances prohibited them to owning one. Maybe they simply love sports cars in general.. I'm 25. So no, my defence is not from experienced knowledge but I can say it isn't biased. ANYWAYS to OP. like everyone else said. If you have things to carry, get G, if not Z. Both are amazing cars and I contemplated the exact same. (But up here in Canada, we do not have "Base" Z.) Styling on Z is definitely much nicer than G IMO stock v stock but i think modified G looks as nice