Which one would you buy? HELP!!

Originally Posted by SINISTER

Okay so the positives of buyin new as I see it are:
1. I run the risk of aftermarket NAV being poorly installed, and maybe having problems in the electrical system,
2. With over 12k miles I run the risk that some toad did not do the appropriate break in period, and pounded the hell out of it for 10 months....
3. He may have even ran it into a pole and had it fixed under the radar so car fax never even picked it up...does it seems strange that they are selling it around 2k below KBB value for a used one?

While for 7k more, I have absolutely no unkowns, as a maintenance and mechanical freak, I baby the car from day 1....with no worries. Worth 7k....???