Trade-in for a Cayman S. :)

papashango · 12-16-2010, 06:27 PM

Nicer ride, meaning more comfortable? Less noise? I thought the cayman s was very loud w the engine behind you

Endgame · 12-16-2010, 09:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeffreyfranz

Yes. I drove a Cayman S extensively on back country roads. I would say it had a huge advantage over the Z I now own, but it definitely had a nicer ride, was arguably more nimble/agile, felt more luxurious and gripped like a cheetah. Pretty impressive, but so is the Z.

I got the Z because it does many of those things quite well, some nearly as well, and the Cayman would have been a stretch for me. The Cayman is still a dream car for me because of the whole of its "positives", but it is important to balance all of these factors. Not to do so is a possible set-up for hardship and worry later. My 2 cents.

This is one reason I went 370. I wanted a cost effective car that could come close to a CS in performance and driving experience. If my old RX8 had 50 more horses and 20 more pound feet of torque, I would have kept it. The Z was the perfect fit for me. Now, I can keep the wife's CX7, the Z, and get that 3 row SUV we need.

ImportConvert · 12-16-2010, 09:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Endgame

This is one reason I went 370. I wanted a cost effective car that could come close to a CS in performance and driving experience. If my old RX8 had 50 more horses and 20 more pound feet of torque, I would have kept it. The Z was the perfect fit for me. Now, I can keep the wife's CX7, the Z, and get that 3 row SUV we need.

The 370Z does so many things that the Cayman does that it's hard not to choose the Z, I would imagine, unless you hate nissan, or love porsche, or are all about a name. I am sure there are many intangibles, but the Z's I drove felt great to me. Of course, this is coming from an old Trans Am with a ton of issues. Still, Porsche needs to up the game with their DI 6-banger in that car. There is a ton of technology in that engine for the power it's producing.

antennahead · 12-16-2010, 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spearfish25

$22.5 is very low. Very low. My 2009 PG 6MT touring/sport 15k miles was just valued at $33k. I think that's high, but you see my point.

I just refinanced my loan to take advantage of lower rates, and my '09 base with sport came in at $30,800 retail. Now you won't get that in trade, but I think $22.5 is a little too low.

cab83_750 · 12-16-2010, 10:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by antennahead

I just refinanced my loan to take advantage of lower rates, and my '09 base with sport came in at $30,800 retail. Now you won't get that in trade, but I think $22.5 is a little too low.

In all honesty and full disclosure, I paid $29K, cash, before taxes. The car is just a base with aero-package ($600.00) The only thing that the car needs at the present time would be new tires. I figured that if I get $23K (+ $1,000 in tires), my actual trade in is $24K.

Might be bad mathematics as I am excluding taxes, but I figure that my actual selling price is $25,000.00 (self-justification

)

antennahead · 12-16-2010, 11:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cab83_750

In all honesty and full disclosure, I paid $29K, cash, before taxes. The car is just a base with aero-package ($600.00) The only thing that the car needs at the present time would be new tires. I figured that if I get $23K (+ $1,000 in tires), my actual trade in is $24K.

Might be bad mathematics as I am excluding taxes, but I figure that my actual selling price is $25,000.00 (self-justification

)

Yea, the good news is the cars are holding their own so far as used book values go, but the reality is if you negotiate well, you can get a new one for the same price as retail used. If you are happy with the deal I'd go for it. You could always ask for a little more and back down if they won't budge.

Oh, and I happen to love the Caymen S. A good friend of mine had one, before the recession caused a downturn in his business. They are great cars. I think the 370 is a better bang for the buck, and he agreed as well. I think the way to go is a mint low mileage used Caymen S, let someone else take the depreciation and get a good deal.

Pushing_Tin · 12-17-2010, 12:10 AM

I got about $24k for my Z on trade. It had it nearly two years. Sport/Touring 16k miles. It was a little low, but we're just starting winter, the economy is still in the shitt*r so I really didn't think I'd be able to get a whole lot more private party, if it sold at all. I looked at all of the closed out E-bay auctions and there were very few selling anywhere for over $26k.

Every comparo I've read puts the Cayman ahead of the Z, even if their numbers on paper are nearly identical. Let us know what happens.

cab83_750 · 12-17-2010, 12:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pushing_Tin

I got about $24k for my Z on trade. It had it nearly two years. Sport/Touring 16k miles. It was a little low, but we're just starting winter, the economy is still in the shitt*r so I really didn't think I'd be able to get a whole lot more private party, if it sold at all. I looked at all of the closed out E-bay auctions and there were very few selling anywhere for over $26k.

Every comparo I've read puts the Cayman ahead of the Z, even if their numbers on paper are nearly identical. Let us know what happens.

.....and you had the "Sports/Touring". Mine is just base --- so I think we all somewhat agree that my actual trade is fair or fair+

Pushing_Tin · 12-17-2010, 01:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cab83_750

.....and you had the "Sports/Touring". Mine is just base --- so I think we all somewhat agree that my actual trade is fair or fair+

Based on the time of year and the market I think it's fair. So here is the current list of closed auctions. 28 closed auctions, TWO sold. One just like mine at $24,786 and a NISMO for $29,999. Some dumbfukker has a 2009 listed at $39K!

http://motors.completed.shop.ebay.co...c0.m283&_rdc=1

Oops, I missed this one, just like yours, a 2009 purchased in 2010. Sold for $24,100.

http://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/2009-...item3cb33e7adf

Pushing_Tin · 12-17-2010, 01:10 AM

This is why I traded, too much BS selling private party and no real increase in sale price.

cab83_750 · 12-17-2010, 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pushing_Tin

This is why I traded, too much BS selling private party and no real increase in sale price.

Thanks for confirming that my analysis of the market is correct.

cab83_750 · 12-17-2010, 02:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by zmyride

I've been contemplating a new cayman s too but my Z sports is only 11 months old , not ready to give it up yet. A new S with taxes would be around $70k I could get two Zs with that money. Dollar for dollar I think a Z is a Better value.

I might just get a couple years old S for around $40k and save about $25k. It's very tempting.

I have never seen an S for $40k. non-s are in the high 30s. Maybe end of 2011, the first gen S could hit high 30s or low 40s.

jeffreyfranz · 12-17-2010, 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by papashango

Nicer ride, meaning more comfortable? Less noise? I thought the cayman s was very loud w the engine behind you

I didn't think it was that loud, but I was working pretty hard and pretty excited as well. By nicer ride, I mean a supple, planted, sticky feeling; great handling/cornering but not at all jarring. However, I cannot remember if it had more, less or the same amount of body roll as our car. But most people who get into cars are going to make mods in the area of suspension, bars, etc., anyway.

jeffreyfranz · 12-17-2010, 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Endgame

This is one reason I went 370. I wanted a cost effective car that could come close to a CS in performance and driving experience. If my old RX8 had 50 more horses and 20 more pound feet of torque, I would have kept it. The Z was the perfect fit for me. Now, I can keep the wife's CX7, the Z, and get that 3 row SUV we need.

Exactly. And I, also, loved my RX-8 and wished for the extra power.

One thing that I never see discussed in the forums that extends this conversation about relative value and what we can afford: If I were driving a nice Cayman S, I would probably hesitate to track it much, worrying that a hairy accident would damage a big investment. And I know I would be obsessing more in parking lots and stuff.

Don't get me wrong: I would still love to have that car. But we got such a great deal. Who else makes a car like this at this price? No one.

Pushing_Tin · 12-17-2010, 06:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jeffreyfranz

Exactly. And I, also, loved my RX-8 and wished for the extra power.

One thing that I never see discussed in the forums that extends this conversation about relative value and what we can afford: If I were driving a nice Cayman S, I would probably hesitate to track it much, worrying that a hairy accident would damage a big investment. And I know I would be obsessing more in parking lots and stuff.

Don't get me wrong: I would still love to have that car. But we got such a great deal. Who else makes a car like this at this price? No one.

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Motivemag: Cayman S vs. 370Z	Endgame	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	47	01-20-2013 05:42 PM
Top Gear 370Z v. Cayman article	semtex	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	140	03-19-2011 10:11 AM
Cayman has cabin noise also	Supremo	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	19	10-27-2009 07:38 AM
Sold the Cayman S, reporting for duty!	Portlander	New Forum Member	8	08-31-2009 06:44 PM
new 370Z video vs. Cayman S	ConchZ2	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	19	08-18-2009 06:11 PM

12-16-2010, 06:27 PM	#106 (permalink)
papashango Base Member Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Northeast Posts: 44 Drives: Japanese Rep Power: 16	Nicer ride, meaning more comfortable? Less noise? I thought the cayman s was very loud w the engine behind you

12-17-2010, 12:10 AM	#112 (permalink)
Pushing_Tin A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Eugene, OR Posts: 2,875 Drives: E63 AMG Rep Power: 229	I got about $24k for my Z on trade. It had it nearly two years. Sport/Touring 16k miles. It was a little low, but we're just starting winter, the economy is still in the shitt*r so I really didn't think I'd be able to get a whole lot more private party, if it sold at all. I looked at all of the closed out E-bay auctions and there were very few selling anywhere for over $26k. Every comparo I've read puts the Cayman ahead of the Z, even if their numbers on paper are nearly identical. Let us know what happens.

12-17-2010, 01:10 AM	#115 (permalink)
Pushing_Tin A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Nov 2008 Location: Eugene, OR Posts: 2,875 Drives: E63 AMG Rep Power: 229	This is why I traded, too much BS selling private party and no real increase in sale price.