Looking for better handling than sport

[jazzmannca]

Hi. Newbie here.. I'm Robert. Nice to meet ya. I just bought a 2010 sportster base w/12K miles on it. Tires need replaced like yesterday. Right now I feel every crack and every bump in the road. It's crazy. Makes it difficult to drive honestly. I immediately turned in my car to an audio shop to get a better stereo and speakers so I'm driving a rental car which happens to be a Camry. Driving the camry is like riding on a cloud. Driving the exact same roads to/from work in the camry you'd think I was in an airplane compared to my new sportster. I bought the sportster for the convertible aspect as well as the power but I'm not a young gun looking to drag race or be stupid with my car. So in choosing new tires which ones should I get that lend more towards comfort and less sport? I hope this makes sense.

Thoughts?