Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Nissan 370Z General Discussions (http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-general-discussions/)
-   -   Trading in GTR for a 370z (http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-general-discussions/28489-trading-gtr-370z.html)

Ztoon 11-30-2010 11:36 PM

Great write-up! Really interesting to get your point of view. Never heard of anybody going from a GTR to a 370 for the fun factor! Really makes me want to re-think my plans, as I was considering going to a GTR or older Gallardo 6 spd. for the bhp fix.

The only negatives I've had with my 370 is the oil heating and burning. Will have to do a consumption test next spring.

Nitrouz 11-30-2010 11:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ztoon (Post 829591)
Great write-up! Really interesting to get your point of view. Never heard of anybody going from a GTR to a 370 for the fun factor! Really makes me want to re-think my plans, as I was considering going to a GTR or older Gallardo 6 spd. for the bhp fix.

The only negatives I've had with my 370 is the oil heating and burning. Will have to do a consumption test next spring.

wow I'm loving your avatar picture. Love the Amuse rear. Do you have any additional pics of your car for some inspiration?

CrownR426 11-30-2010 11:46 PM

D:
...
I'd keep the R35 over a Z34 anyday...
Hope you know what you're doing esp since you in Canada..
More power to you!

DIGItonium 11-30-2010 11:59 PM

Ah your user name looked so familiar. I remember your Z very much. You're the reason why I'm so in love with the Volk GT-S wheels! That's why I ordered a set of formula silver GT-S wheels for the 370Z. In fact, I used to have Volk LE-37t with the 350Z.

I'm trying to find a shop within a 10 hour driving distance that would install and tune the GTM TT kit early next year. [sigh] For awhile I was thinking about giving up and sell the Z for an '02+ NSX. [shrugs]

Ztoon 12-01-2010 12:09 AM

4 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitrouz (Post 829601)
wow I'm loving your avatar picture. Love the Amuse rear. Do you have any additional pics of your car for some inspiration?

Thanks man! Love to see your 350 as well, if you've got any pics to share.

Here's a few thumbnails. Got a bunch more on my albums profile page.

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 12:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DIGItonium (Post 829620)
Ah your user name looked so familiar. I remember your Z very much. You're the reason why I'm so in love with the Volk GT-S wheels! That's why I ordered a set of formula silver GT-S wheels for the 370Z. In fact, I used to have Volk LE-37t with the 350Z.

I'm trying to find a shop within a 10 hour driving distance that would install and tune the GTM TT kit early next year. [sigh] For awhile I was thinking about giving up and sell the Z for an '02+ NSX. [shrugs]

I remember you too. From my350z. Yeah I was the first in the US to have the GTS wheels. Went through 3 sets of them. Being sponsored by Rays helps lol...

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 12:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ztoon (Post 829632)
Thanks man! Love to see your 350 as well, if you've got any pics to share.

Here's a few thumbnails. Got a bunch more on my albums profile page.

wow I'm loving everything about your car. Well done!

Here are some pics of my old Z... and some with my GTR.

http://img101.imageshack.us/img101/2629/img1158dp7.jpg

http://img159.imageshack.us/img159/1...overwebuu7.jpg

http://img253.imageshack.us/img253/3...hoot033kl5.jpg

http://img249.imageshack.us/img249/7...8spreaday1.jpg

http://img156.imageshack.us/img156/7153/99545432ef2.jpg

http://img825.imageshack.us/img825/3674/alexscars.jpg

http://img230.imageshack.us/img230/4796/img5084kr0.jpg

http://img683.imageshack.us/img683/7...ition019ba.jpg

http://img713.imageshack.us/img713/4012/img0495r.jpg

doubleG370Z 12-01-2010 12:30 AM

your 350Z was sick, can't wait to see what you come up with for the 370Z...welcome back!

shoopajae10 12-01-2010 12:38 AM

I want your GTR! Take my Z!

Mt Tam I am 12-01-2010 12:40 AM

I appreciate Nitrouz's position. I originally went to buy a GTR and when I found out it only came in automatic, I bought the Z. Enjoy the new car Nitrouz.

Jamaica 12-01-2010 12:43 AM

Looks another great build to come. Im in for results

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 12:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamaica951 (Post 829674)
Looks another great build to come. Im in for results

can you hook me up with Amuse parts? :yum:

SVTNate 12-01-2010 12:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mt Tam I am (Post 829671)
I originally went to buy a GTR and when I found out the price, I bought the Z

That's more along the lines of what happened to me :icon18: j/k

Hrm. GT-R is a great car, but you want something more raw, more dangerous, more exciting. I'm a motorcycle guy first and foremost. I'd keep the GT-R and pick up a Ducati 1198S, MV Agusta F4, or an Aprilia RSV4 Factory. It is simply not possible to get the thrill of a high performance motorcycle in anything with four wheels IMO. Of course, if you aren't an experienced rider already, I'd avoid any of those choices for the next few years :icon17:

Jamaica 12-01-2010 01:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitrouz (Post 829679)
can you hook me up with Amuse parts? :yum:

Ha just let me know!

Ztoon 12-01-2010 01:02 AM

You definitely know how to put it together! Nice seeing a functioning diffuser.
Will really enjoy following your 370 build!

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 01:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitrouz (Post 829293)
Hello,

I've just contacted my dealership to find me a 370z (no Z's left on their lot) and I will trade in my GTR for it. I'm just debating between black and blue... unsure which color I like more.

The last time I remember REALLY enjoying driving, was when I was driving my stock block 350Z with an APS TT kit. Simple TT kit on a stock block conservatively tuned, nice suspension, simple bodykit, wheels and tires. Nice unique little pocket rocket. Since then, I've spent a lot of money and time and built up the Z into a complete daily drivable show car. Lots of fun, but sometime in the build, it became more hassle than actual, uninhibited FUN. Always had to keep an eye on the gauges, listening to sounds, refilling water/meth, worrying if I want to go for a long distance road trip, etc.

Therefore I went for the GTR. With the GTR, it's an AWD all-season car, to the full extent. Fast, unique, 4 seater, good sized trunk, dual-clutch tranny, easily tunable, etc. Makes sense right? I spent the last 2 1/2 years of my life with the daily driven GTR. Full exhaust, intake, HKS BOV's, Cobb custom tune, wheels, suspension, lip kit, etc. Nice and simple. Sounds amazing. Makes sense in every aspect to keep it. However, I overlooked the most basic and primal factor in driving......the "fun". Don't get me wrong, the GTR is extremely fun on the racetrack, blowing past 911 turbos, GT3's, Lambos, Ferraris, etc. But on the street where I spend 90% of my driving time? Not so much. Fully stable and full of traction, it is not "fun" until you pass 140mph in a high speed corner. Yes it goes from 0-60 in under 3 seconds, but that's as much fun as it gets on the street. For me at least.

Therefore I've decided to go back to basics. 370z, simple GTM 500whp kit, wheels, suspension, kit, some other aesthetics. Simple little pocket rocket where I can have fun at 40mph instead of having to push up to 150+mph to have fun.

Now...I've been researching on this forum over the past few days. Great site btw. Read some of the little problems with the 370z (overheating, etc). Other than that, has anyone here found anything really annoying with the 370z? Not something everyone would KNOW from a test drive...but actually living with the car, any EMOTIONAL disappointments? I'm not looking for the fastest car. I'm not looking for the rarest. I'm looking for something that is rewarding emotionally everytime I get into the driver seat.

Any input would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you,

Alex

Yep, hence why the GT-R is a fat pig with a manumatic in my opinion. It posts great race-track numbers, but a simple mustang GT will emberrass one from a freeway roll while your automatic's computer struggles to pick the right gear and the GT has shat and gone and clowned you and if he lets off by 100, you look a fool and end up doing a ricer fly-by to feel better about things once the PCM finally decides which gear to jump into after you floor it.

Might as well pay someone to drive it for you. "Floor it James, now! NOW!"

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 01:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SVTNate (Post 829690)
That's more along the lines of what happened to me :icon18: j/k

Hrm. GT-R is a great car, but you want something more raw, more dangerous, more exciting. I'm a motorcycle guy first and foremost. I'd keep the GT-R and pick up a Ducati 1198S, MV Agusta F4, or an Aprilia RSV4 Factory. It is simply not possible to get the thrill of a high performance motorcycle in anything with four wheels IMO. Of course, if you aren't an experienced rider already, I'd avoid any of those choices for the next few years :icon17:

my last bike....... right before I picked up my 1198S. :hello:

http://img195.imageshack.us/img195/4207/img2383r.jpg

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 01:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImportConvert (Post 829707)
Yep, hence why the GT-R is a fat pig with a manumatic in my opinion. It posts great race-track numbers, but a simple mustang GT will emberrass one from a freeway roll while your automatic's computer struggles to pick the right gear and the GT has shat and gone and clowned you and if he lets off by 100, you look a fool and end up doing a ricer fly-by to feel better about things once the PCM finally decides which gear to jump into after you floor it.

Might as well pay someone to drive it for you. "Floor it James, now! NOW!"

I don't agree with you there. I wouldn't go that far. It's an engineering marvel, I must say. Having owned it for 2 1/2 years, you'd be hard pressed to find a GTR owner that drives it in auto mode most of the time. We're always in manual mode. Best combo is in manual mode, Trans=Race / Susp=Comf / VDC=Normal for daily driving. Haven't had any Mustang GT's beat me yet. :)

SVTNate 12-01-2010 01:27 AM

Well ****, that's fantastic. Personally I don't have a need to own a really exciting car when a great motorcycle is in the garage. When I want to hit a great canyon or mountain road, I'd rather be on two wheels 100% of the time.

What sort of riding do you do on the 1198 (and the 848 you had)? I've been thinking about the new 848 EVO, but I think pure sport bikes are too uncomfortable for a proper 400-500 mile day ride. I'm going to pick up a white 2011 Speed Triple with flyscreen/belly pan/Arrow low mount when they are released early next year.

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 01:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SVTNate (Post 829767)
Well ****, that's fantastic. Personally I don't have a need to own a really exciting car when a great motorcycle is in the garage. When I want to hit a great canyon or mountain road, I'd rather be on two wheels 100% of the time.

What sort of riding do you do on the 1198 (and the 848 you had)? I've been thinking about the new 848 EVO, but I think pure sport bikes are too uncomfortable for a proper 400-500 mile day ride. I'm going to pick up a white 2011 Speed Triple with flyscreen/belly pan/Arrow low mount when they are released early next year.

I do a lot of mountain carving / back roads here in BC. We have a lot of nice secluded roads up high in the mountains. Roads are twisty, long, well-maintained. Some continuous 2nd gear bends and some high speed 4th to 5th gear bends, all mixed together. We're blessed here with these roads.

But you're right, they're not comfortable at all if you're looking for a full day ride. Especially with a Duc, the v-twin vibration through the wrists will hurt the next day, guaranteed. But the sound is mesmorizing, I must admit.

SVTNate 12-01-2010 01:35 AM

V Twin vibration is only bad because you're in that committed riding position I suspect. I think the vibes of a twin or triple are generally not as bad as an I4.

We have some great roads here in Southern California, but most of them are an hour's ride (on the freeway) from where I live. I'm looking at 3 hours of seat time minimum for a day ride long and aggressive enough for my tastes.

Nitrouz 12-01-2010 01:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SVTNate (Post 829787)
V Twin vibration is only bad because you're in that committed riding position I suspect. I think the vibes of a twin or triple are generally not as bad as an I4.

We have some great roads here in Southern California, but most of them are an hour's ride (on the freeway) from where I live. I'm looking at 3 hours of seat time minimum for a day ride long and aggressive enough for my tastes.

I've lived in both northern and southern california. There are some great great roads, but I prefer the BC back roads here. I've had many, many bikes, and none vibrates as much as a duc's v-twin. With a Duc's sportbike, you can't be in any position but the committed position. You're not as upright as a gixxer for example. It's seating position is more like a Yammy. High seat, low clip-ons. Forcing you to put weight into the wrists.

WWJD 12-01-2010 02:09 AM

ahhh, I know what you are saying. Driving on freeway is kind of bore in the GTR, unless having someone trying to race. I'm going to pick up a Z too, but not trading in my GTR for sure.

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 02:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitrouz (Post 829765)
I don't agree with you there. I wouldn't go that far. It's an engineering marvel, I must say. Having owned it for 2 1/2 years, you'd be hard pressed to find a GTR owner that drives it in auto mode most of the time. We're always in manual mode. Best combo is in manual mode, Trans=Race / Susp=Comf / VDC=Normal for daily driving. Haven't had any Mustang GT's beat me yet. :)

So basically, you bought an automatic and like to pretend it's a manual? I had a friend in highschool do that with his 4-speed auto mustang. Always had his hand on the shifter, etc. like he was going to do something.

I know the DCT is a great transmission and offers fast/crisp shifts, etc. but there is just something missing when you can't stab a clutch pedal I think.

What is upkeep like? I heard that Nissan has VERY expensive 10K etc. service intervals for it. True or lie?

MC 12-01-2010 02:39 AM

:facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm: :facepalm:

Jamaica 12-01-2010 02:41 AM

alot of high end sports car are now coming in a DCT. DO people think its less of a sports car cause of that?

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 03:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by jamaica951 (Post 829936)
alot of high end sports car are now coming in a DCT. DO people think its less of a sports car cause of that?

Certainly not, and I will be the first to admit that a manumatic is going to shift faster than me, but that's missing the point for 99% of the users who actually drive the car for fun and not because they have to have the biggest pecker or because they compete for $$ or whatnot.

You don't drop near 6-figures on a car because you think it will beat another car by .1 second to 60 mph (well, some people might, I guess.). You drop that kind of money for the smile it brings to your face when you drive it. To me, being insulated with all these technological gatgets and widgets, I would be better off just paying a pro driver to drive it for me. No, I smile when stabbing a clutch and jamming some gears. Flicking a lever, not so much.

The GT-R is of course a fast car that lays down great numbers. It just doesn't need any help from you to do it, and that's kindof taking the fun out of things. It's like owning a rifle that aims itself. Cool trick, but going to the range or hitting that big buck just wouldn't make you feel so good after a few times.

Cyberium 12-01-2010 04:18 AM

Question... what the F do you guys do for work?

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 04:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyberium (Post 829999)
Question... what the F do you guys do for work?

Not a GT-R owner, so not sure if that was directed at me, but I am an RN,BSN, and work on a stepdown unit. Hoping to buy a Z06 early next year--because I like to shift my own. :tiphat:

BennytheBlade 12-01-2010 06:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cyberium (Post 829999)
Question... what the F do you guys do for work?

Lol.
Some of this doesn't seem appropriate on a forum dedicated to the best bang for ur buck sports car around, does it?:icon17:


More on topic- while I thought all the technical stuff on the gtr was amazing, and offers some amazing track/driving abilities (the launch of the gtr almost had me sold right there) it does give a little insulation or disconnect from the driving experience as a whole... My limited experience of course.

Jeffblue 12-01-2010 06:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImportConvert (Post 829981)
Certainly not, and I will be the first to admit that a manumatic is going to shift faster than me, but that's missing the point for 99% of the users who actually drive the car for fun and not because they have to have the biggest pecker or because they compete for $$ or whatnot.

You don't drop near 6-figures on a car because you think it will beat another car by .1 second to 60 mph (well, some people might, I guess.). You drop that kind of money for the smile it brings to your face when you drive it. To me, being insulated with all these technological gatgets and widgets, I would be better off just paying a pro driver to drive it for me. No, I smile when stabbing a clutch and jamming some gears. Flicking a lever, not so much.

The GT-R is of course a fast car that lays down great numbers. It just doesn't need any help from you to do it, and that's kindof taking the fun out of things. It's like owning a rifle that aims itself. Cool trick, but going to the range or hitting that big buck just wouldn't make you feel so good after a few times.

The shifts in a GTR with its dual clutch transmission is so much faster than what your friends mustang GT was, its a totally different animal. I'm a stick shift guy too, and i wouldn't get a car that doesn't come in stick (at least for right now) but honestly, go drive an F1 car or a lemans car, and tell me how bored you are.

I think you're preaching to the chior though. the OP came in here stating that he was bored of the GTR and wanted exactly what you are talking about

DIGItonium 12-01-2010 07:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nitrouz (Post 829641)
I remember you too. From my350z. Yeah I was the first in the US to have the GTS wheels. Went through 3 sets of them. Being sponsored by Rays helps lol...

:tiphat: Yup been there since JManZ days... getting old HA!

The 370Z is definitely a fun project car. The biggest gripe for me is that it lacks punch under 3k RPM, so it doesn't "feel" fast. Beyond 3k it pulls all the way to redline. The 350Z, on the other hand, had great neck snapping low end response. It came alive around 4k RPM, but it did not pull as hard as the 370Z. Well... that's how I felt :driving:

I seriously debated skipping TT, selling everything, and look for an '02+ NSX because I wanted a more raw feeling. It's probably not the fastest, but it probably feels fast and is more fun to drive. I've never been in one so I can't say much. On the other hand, MC's GT-R is such a great deal as well for roughly the same price as a used NSX, but I would prefer to keep the manual gear box.

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 07:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jeffblue (Post 830021)
The shifts in a GTR with its dual clutch transmission is so much faster than what your friends mustang GT was, its a totally different animal. I'm a stick shift guy too, and i wouldn't get a car that doesn't come in stick (at least for right now) but honestly, go drive an F1 car or a lemans car, and tell me how bored you are.

I think you're preaching to the chior though. the OP came in here stating that he was bored of the GTR and wanted exactly what you are talking about

It's not the shift, it's the down-shift while the computer tries to figure out which gear is best once you matt the accelerator. The shift happens fast, the "thinking" is the slow part.

Quote:

Originally Posted by BennytheBlade (Post 830013)
Lol.
Some of this doesn't seem appropriate on a forum dedicated to the best bang for ur buck sports car around, does it?:icon17:


More on topic- while I thought all the technical stuff on the gtr was amazing, and offers some amazing track/driving abilities (the launch of the gtr almost had me sold right there) it does give a little insulation or disconnect from the driving experience as a whole... My limited experience of course.

You mean acceleration? The GT-R does not have a "launch" if you mean "launch control". That is a feature expressly used for getting the car out of mud or snow. Says so in the manual. Use it for anything else, and your warranty is void.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DIGItonium (Post 830043)
:tiphat: Yup been there since JManZ days... getting old HA!

The 370Z is definitely a fun project car. The biggest gripe for me is that it lacks punch under 3k RPM, so it doesn't "feel" fast. Beyond 3k it pulls all the way to redline. The 350Z, on the other hand, had great neck snapping low end response. It came alive around 4k RPM, but it did not pull as hard as the 370Z. Well... that's how I felt :driving:

I seriously debated skipping TT, selling everything, and look for an '02+ NSX because I wanted a more raw feeling. It's probably not the fastest, but it probably feels fast and is more fun to drive. I've never been in one so I can't say much. On the other hand, MC's GT-R is such a great deal as well for roughly the same price as a used NSX, but I would prefer to keep the manual gear box.

Keep your 370Z. I think the 370 is much faster, based on the NSX I stomped and what people tell me the 370Z can do. The NSX is old technology--VERY WELL thought-out, but old. Total collector item, though. Apples to oranges with the GT-R. If you want to compre something to the GT-R, you will have to check out a used GT2, which will still cost a lot more, or a used Z06, which doesn't have quite the attention to detail/theme.

BennytheBlade 12-01-2010 08:05 AM

Just the punch of awd and the great ability/adjustability of the car for 0-60 ( and just about everything else for that matter).

As for the warranty, I'm not worried about that on any car that isn't my DD.
Heck the salesman was the one who showed me how to turn it off. Granted he told me not to rev up and to take it ez but he was thinking about selling me the car at that point. Almost worked too.

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 08:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BennytheBlade (Post 830063)
Just the punch of awd and the great ability/adjustability of the car for 0-60 ( and just about everything else for that matter).

As for the warranty, I'm not worried about that on any car that isn't my DD.
Heck the salesman was the one who showed me how to turn it off. Granted he told me not to rev up and to take it ez but he was thinking about selling me the car at that point. Almost worked too.

I suppose. I don't make enough $$ to replace a $20K transmission off the cuff, though, and I don't want my "fun" car sitting for the time it would take me to raise the $$ while I payed a note on a 2-tonne paper-weight.

Reality 12-01-2010 08:29 AM

Can't wait to see how you transform her, Alex!
-I am looking at a blue one myself.. should have another z by spring..:tup:

Msn coming your way!

ImportConvert 12-01-2010 08:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Reality (Post 830072)
Can't wait to see how you transform her, Alex!
-I am looking at a blue one myself.. should have another z by spring..:tup:

Msn coming your way!

+1, your 350 was the nicest I have seen!

m4a1mustang 12-01-2010 08:37 AM

There have been a few times when I seriously considered trading my 370Z in on a GTR. Even once or twice with my Mustang I thought about it. But kind of along the same lines as what you've described, I felt like both the Z and Mustang are probably more fun to drive on the street.

Ultimately I think I have to have a proper manual transmission. Without a doubt I will be buying DC automatics in the future, but there will always have to be at least one old-school manual transmission sports car in my stable. Do want a Ferrari... probably a 550/575 in a few years when I've got the space to keep it garaged. :)

Anyhoo, can't wait to see what you do with your 370. That 350 was awesome.

BennytheBlade 12-01-2010 08:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ImportConvert (Post 830066)
I don't want my "fun" car sitting .

Absolutely.
I hope I'm not giving the impression that the gtr is the greatest thing on planet earth, I mean I did go w/ the Z. I was just particularly impressed w/ the launch/acceleration of the gtr from a dead stop.


Anyhow op, if this 370 turns out like your 350, I am really looking forward see what u do. Hope u keep us informed:driving:.

HKYStormFront 12-01-2010 08:42 AM

alex, you can't sell your GTR before i get up there to shoot :mad: bet some NAGTROC folk will jump all over your volks if you want to sell them. i understand that it's cheaper to daily drive a Z but seems to me that you will have almost as much in the Z as the GTR by the time you get it set up the way you want it... but it's your decision. either way, i'm sure if you get a Z it will be one of the best looking ones out there since your 350 certainly was :tiphat:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:26 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2