Would you feel the same way or am I overreacting?

quarryninja

So last week I was stopped in a red light and all of a sudden the guy in front of me shifts into reverse and hits my front bumper.

The damage amounted to only a small dent and some paint scratches (keep in mind that my Z was only a weak old at the time).

After dealing with the paperwork and waiting for things to get sorted out with the insurance company the verdict was that they were not going to change the bumper, the dealer said they were only going to fix and respray. If this happened to you would you settle for this? Or would you demand a new bumper? Will the repair leave it just as good as new? Something I should specifically check for (quality wise) when I get the car back to know if they did a good job?

I know I probably won't notice anything after they fix it, but deep down I'll still know that my baby had a dent in it.

Bonus question:
I am planning on getting it Xpel'd soon. If this were to have happened with the Xpel on does your insurance cover that cost as well?

Hope to get some input from you guys.