[OFFICIAL] Manual v. Automatic Thread

Felix 808 · 12-03-2011, 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cossie1600

Did you really compare the Ferrari auto to the 370 auto? Yikes

Not so much, just saying, autos are not the slip-o-matics they were years ago & you will find them in high-end sports-cars as well.

Mt Tam I am · 12-03-2011, 10:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Endgame

Went for a test drive in the 7AT yesterday. It is an amazing transmission, but I strongly felt I lost something when compared to the 6MT I tested a few months back.

The shifts were fast, but I did not feel connected to the car; felt more like I was floating. The odd this is that I feel more connected to the car in my wife's CX7 with the tranny in Sport mode than the Z with the 7AT..... My test yesterday confirmed I will be getting the 6MT. More control, more fun...

Couldn't agree more.

cossie1600 · 12-03-2011, 10:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Felix 808

Not so much, just saying, autos are not the slip-o-matics they were years ago & you will find them in high-end sports-cars as well.

I would love to get a DSG Audi TT, but then they still have their drawbacks like the automatic upshifts/downshifts (not sure if the Z has it). I think the new auto on the Porsche is overrated too, not feeling it

UNKNOWN_370 · 12-04-2011, 12:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nismo89

lol simply put: its a Z. just like all others on this forum. thats what im justifying lol

what are you 12? Did daddy buy you your Z or something?

Dude do you not read your posts for content? Right now you sound like a borderline troll. I'm not even going to take you to school. It wouldn't make sense ssince the posts on this thread make you sound like a reject from the Scion forums.
If you think the GTR isn't a sports car then you obviously don't know smack about performance vehicles. That's just my opinion though.

Super Moderator II · 12-04-2011, 01:00 AM

And .... that's all folks!

rhd · 03-01-2012, 06:48 AM

Hi,

I am looking to buy a 370 in a month or two; I’m checking the market place forum and also auto trader. I want something with under 20K miles in maybe a sport package.

My question is: how does the automatic transmission perform vs. the manual?

I grew up driving a manual transmission and was planning on buying this 370 with a manual but I see allot of automatics for sale on autotrader that look really nice for pretty good prices.

I am going to use the car as a daily driver to and from work on mostly open highways and some winding highway. I will be the only one driving it, the wifey has her suv.

Can the automatic be used similar to a manual if you wanted? How is the reliability of the automatic if a person shifted it manually allot? If I bought an automatic and wanted to do some serious canyon carving would I be disappointed with the automatic?

I am looking for feedback on your experiences and thoughts with a manual vs. automatic trannys.

Thanks,

John - Montana

kenchan · 03-01-2012, 07:00 AM

No, get the manual.

Ibtl

jpritche · 03-01-2012, 07:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kenchan

No, get the manual.

Ibtl

Quote:

Originally Posted by rhd

Hi,

I am looking to buy a 370 in a month or two; I’m checking the market place forum and also auto trader. I want something with under 20K miles in maybe a sport package.

My question is: how does the automatic transmission perform vs. the manual?

I grew up driving a manual transmission and was planning on buying this 370 with a manual but I see allot of automatics for sale on autotrader that look really nice for pretty good prices.

I am going to use the car as a daily driver to and from work on mostly open highways and some winding highway. I will be the only one driving it, the wifey has her suv.

Can the automatic be used similar to a manual if you wanted? How is the reliability of the automatic if a person shifted it manually allot? If I bought an automatic and wanted to do some serious canyon carving would I be disappointed with the automatic?

I am looking for feedback on your experiences and thoughts with a manual vs. automatic trannys.

Thanks,

John - Montana

For the AVERAGE driver, the automatic tends to be just a smidge faster.

The automatic can be used sort of like a manual. You can choose the gear you are in, and you choose when you shift.

I have the automatic, and I have loved it the whole time I have had it. I haven't been disappointed with it at all.

However, I agree with Kenchan on this. I love the automatic don't get me wrong, but if I could go back, I would have gotten the manual. After college, I plan to go FI, but I have to watch how high my torque gets because the auto can't handle as much as the manual. Plus, you just don't get the same feel with an auto. Go manual. IMO.

Gauge · 03-01-2012, 07:10 AM

It's a RWD car... get a manual lol

From what I hear the automatic is good for some fun. I don't think it would disappoint.

XwChriswX · 03-01-2012, 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rhd

Hi,

I am looking to buy a 370 in a month or two; I’m checking the market place forum and also auto trader. I want something with under 20K miles in maybe a sport package.

My question is: how does the automatic transmission perform vs. the manual?

I grew up driving a manual transmission and was planning on buying this 370 with a manual but I see allot of automatics for sale on autotrader that look really nice for pretty good prices.

I am going to use the car as a daily driver to and from work on mostly open highways and some winding highway. I will be the only one driving it, the wifey has her suv.

Can the automatic be used similar to a manual if you wanted? Yes
How is the reliability of the automatic if a person shifted it manually allot? 32k and no problems as of yet.
If I bought an automatic and wanted to do some serious canyon carving would I be disappointed with the automatic? Not in the least. It makes timing downshifts fun.

I am looking for feedback on your experiences and thoughts with a manual vs. automatic trannys.

Thanks,

John - Montana

yellogixxer · 03-01-2012, 07:18 AM

I was in the market for a manual before I bought my Z. I've always been of the mindset that a sports car should have a manual. You should drive it, not just aim it where you want to go. That being said, I ended up in a 7AT. The car I ended up with had everything else that I wanted (color, options, etc) except the trans.

Driving the auto is obviously different, and even now, a month and a half after I bought it I still ponder whether I made the right decision. I've been using the paddle shifters as opposed to the console shifter. I find you have good control over upshifting; you shift when you are ready, and the car responds immediately. Downshifting is another story. In a manual you downshift and use engine braking a lot. Not with this car. She will downshift on her own, when she deems necessary, and I don't believe there is anyway to bypass this. Downshifting yourself sometimes leads to downshifting 2 gears at a time, and thrashing the car a bit. Downshifting should only be used when you need to hit the power band for acceleration.

In my opinion, if you want to drive it like a sports car, get the manual. If you drive in traffic a lot and are okay with point and drive most of the time, go with the auto.

ImportConvert · 03-01-2012, 07:31 AM

Both are reliable, the auto is faster by far for a novice drag racer, and a tiny tiny bit for a skilled drag racer. The manual is a lot more fun.since you will be on the freeway, that meaner just stick it in sixth and kick back. On those windy roads, tons more fun. So unless this car is meant for drag or bracket racing for money--go manual.

Lemers · 03-01-2012, 07:38 AM

Autos are for girls and family wagons

Red__Zed · 03-01-2012, 07:52 AM

Ibtl

ImportConvert · 03-01-2012, 07:53 AM

Yeah, threads about trannys usually get locked.

03-01-2012, 06:48 AM	#321 (permalink)
rhd Enthusiast Member Join Date: Feb 2012 Location: In the shop Posts: 281 Drives: Women Crazy Rep Power: 13	Manual vs. Automatic Tranny? Hi, I am looking to buy a 370 in a month or two; I’m checking the market place forum and also auto trader. I want something with under 20K miles in maybe a sport package. My question is: how does the automatic transmission perform vs. the manual? I grew up driving a manual transmission and was planning on buying this 370 with a manual but I see allot of automatics for sale on autotrader that look really nice for pretty good prices. I am going to use the car as a daily driver to and from work on mostly open highways and some winding highway. I will be the only one driving it, the wifey has her suv. Can the automatic be used similar to a manual if you wanted? How is the reliability of the automatic if a person shifted it manually allot? If I bought an automatic and wanted to do some serious canyon carving would I be disappointed with the automatic? I am looking for feedback on your experiences and thoughts with a manual vs. automatic trannys. Thanks, John - Montana

03-01-2012, 07:18 AM	#326 (permalink)
yellogixxer Base Member Join Date: Jan 2012 Location: Reading, Pa Posts: 248 Drives: 07 C6 M6 Cpe Rep Power: 13	I was in the market for a manual before I bought my Z. I've always been of the mindset that a sports car should have a manual. You should drive it, not just aim it where you want to go. That being said, I ended up in a 7AT. The car I ended up with had everything else that I wanted (color, options, etc) except the trans. Driving the auto is obviously different, and even now, a month and a half after I bought it I still ponder whether I made the right decision. I've been using the paddle shifters as opposed to the console shifter. I find you have good control over upshifting; you shift when you are ready, and the car responds immediately. Downshifting is another story. In a manual you downshift and use engine braking a lot. Not with this car. She will downshift on her own, when she deems necessary, and I don't believe there is anyway to bypass this. Downshifting yourself sometimes leads to downshifting 2 gears at a time, and thrashing the car a bit. Downshifting should only be used when you need to hit the power band for acceleration. In my opinion, if you want to drive it like a sports car, get the manual. If you drive in traffic a lot and are okay with point and drive most of the time, go with the auto. __________________ '07 C6 6MT Coupe 03 Accord, DD, 400k miles

03-01-2012, 07:38 AM	#328 (permalink)
Lemers A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Mar 2010 Location: Izmir, Turkey Posts: 15,371 Drives: 2012 Traverse LTZ Rep Power: 52	Autos are for girls and family wagons __________________ 2010 Black Cherry Touring/Sport/Nav Now - 2012 Travese LTZ until I leave for Turkey

Thread Tools
Show Printable Version Email this Page
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Automatic or Manual?	z9015	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	34	03-18-2015 04:23 PM
manual vs automatic question	CameronSean	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	4	05-14-2013 09:59 PM
Automatic or Manual?	370Znj	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	2	01-17-2013 01:54 AM
Manual or Automatic - What do you have?	Zdom	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	46	02-02-2010 07:52 PM
Manual vs automatic	wanta370	Nissan 370Z General Discussions	7	08-19-2009 12:09 AM

12-04-2011, 01:00 AM	#320 (permalink)
Super Moderator II Super Moderator Join Date: Feb 2011 Location: Earth Posts: 379 Drives: a Spaceship Rep Power: 6264	And .... that's all folks!

03-01-2012, 07:00 AM	#322 (permalink)
kenchan A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: N/A Posts: 76,801 Drives: N/A Rep Power: 141520	No, get the manual. Ibtl

03-01-2012, 07:10 AM	#324 (permalink)
Gauge Track Member Join Date: Sep 2011 Location: Madison WI Posts: 867 Drives: 2012 370Z Nismo PW Rep Power: 14	It's a RWD car... get a manual lol From what I hear the automatic is good for some fun. I don't think it would disappoint.

03-01-2012, 07:31 AM	#327 (permalink)
ImportConvert A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: SWMO Posts: 4,454 Drives: 2019 CX5 GT Reserve Rep Power: 7626	Both are reliable, the auto is faster by far for a novice drag racer, and a tiny tiny bit for a skilled drag racer. The manual is a lot more fun.since you will be on the freeway, that meaner just stick it in sixth and kick back. On those windy roads, tons more fun. So unless this car is meant for drag or bracket racing for money--go manual.

03-01-2012, 07:52 AM	#329 (permalink)
Red__Zed A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Jul 2010 Location: window seat Posts: 28,940 Drives: Mostly on two wheels Rep Power: 119	Ibtl

03-01-2012, 07:53 AM	#330 (permalink)
ImportConvert A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Jun 2010 Location: SWMO Posts: 4,454 Drives: 2019 CX5 GT Reserve Rep Power: 7626	Yeah, threads about trannys usually get locked.