Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Other Vehicles (http://www.the370z.com/other-vehicles/)
-   -   curious just how much of a diff does a superior car make? (http://www.the370z.com/other-vehicles/50276-curious-just-how-much-diff-does-superior-car-make.html)

brucelidat 02-26-2012 01:56 AM

So basically, you'd have to be a pretty advanced driver in a Z to be faster than a semi-competent (not good, but not terrible, maybe has a few days of exp) guy in a GT-R?

shadoquad 02-26-2012 02:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cossie1600 (Post 1566163)
Its really hard to make up nearly 160hp and awd traction. I have a datalog between both caes. You will be amazed at how mucj faster the gtr is. You just need a semi competent driver

But I'm sure you agree that driver skill and experience can make up quite a bit of difference. You've logged some seat time. :D

brucelidat 02-26-2012 02:09 AM

well, I guess if you're on the track at the same time and the GT-R is behind you, it would be pretty hard to beat him since he could just follow your lines and punch it past you on a straight...

brucelidat 02-26-2012 02:11 AM

at my first track day ever, i was behind my friend who is a better driver in his old miata, and I followed his lines and passed him on the straight since i have like triple his power, but he passed me again after a few more turns, haha.

kenchan 02-26-2012 07:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brucelidat (Post 1566197)
at my first track day ever, i was behind my friend who is a better driver in his old miata, and I followed his lines and passed him on the straight since i have like triple his power, but he passed me again after a few more turns, haha.

Did he say "too soon junior!" ?

cossie1600 02-26-2012 08:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brucelidat (Post 1566169)
So basically, you'd have to be a pretty advanced driver in a Z to be faster than a semi-competent (not good, but not terrible, maybe has a few days of exp) guy in a GT-R?

Yes, but too many variable. That's why you are better off comparing lap times rather than positioning on the track. Also to their defense, I would assume for most people it is harder to push a 80K car vs. a 30K car.

I am not sure how familiar you are with reading telemetry. Here is a picture of a lap comparing this guy's GT-R and my best run. You can see exactly where I am gaining and losing time to him on the graph below. And I know for a fact he was another sec or two quicker when he was following me when I did my best lap. Also he was nowhere close to the edge when he pushed for the time below.

http://img836.imageshack.us/img836/7184/370zgtr.jpg

Uploaded with ImageShack.us

Mt Tam I am 02-26-2012 08:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by brucelidat (Post 1566000)
So I was at the track today, I'm a newbie BTW, and notice there are is a huge assortment of cars with major variations in power out there at the same time (my beginner group had plenty of vettes, a ferrari, GTR, 2 CTS-Vs, etc.) So it got me thinking, the GT-R is obviously superior to the Z in every way (except looks IMO), but would a newbie like me be significantly faster in one? Just how big of a difference does that superior power and handling make? Would a novice GTR driver be faster than an intermediate Z driver? Would a GTR driver with just a few track days of exp be faster than an intermediate or higher level Z driver? I am just curious because basically anytime see a GTR behind me, I'm already looking ahead tot he next passing zone to let him by. Any thoughts on this form guys who have maybe tracked both or at least 2 cars that ar eon 2 very different levels of performance?

I did a track day in August. My first with the Z. I took a half day class in a Formula 3 car before this. Not very similar. http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-g...chool-day.html

A GTR was present. Our test to get on the track was a cone course. The GTR driver was lagging until the final timed event and took third. Cones are not the same as open tracking, but this was the result.

Oddly enough I saw this car yesterday for the first time. I was waiting at a 5 minute red light when I saw a GTR stop behind me I gave him the thumbs up. He got out and said I know you. Sure enough he is the same GTR from Sears Point. He never sent photos of my car he took in August so I hope he sends them this time.

ZSIZZLE 02-26-2012 09:00 AM

i run a nissan dealership and i have about 20 trackdays under my belt with a 500whp bmw m6, now i have taken many customers to track days with there gtr's and they consistently put up times close to or better than much more experienced drivers in other cars. you still have to break properly and hit your apex but the gtr makes it easier to do it, you take a bad line and try to force a correction the gtr makes it easier, the other big thing is the throttle and the car rotating, my m6 i gotta baby the gas pedal in 2nd out of a turn, in the gtr its mash and go!!!! a tenth faster here a tenth faster there, a few tenths worth of good shifting and the car will mask allot!!!

ZSIZZLE 02-26-2012 09:03 AM

also all you have to look at is the ring times, the gtr is like number 4 out of every car on the planet that way allot less and have way more power, thats including your enzo's, carerra gt, italia, mp412c, all the hyper cars!!!! the zr1,viper, and a couple of others beat the gtr

Mt Tam I am 02-26-2012 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZSIZZLE (Post 1566374)
i run a nissan dealership and i have about 20 trackdays under my belt with a 500whp bmw m6, now i have taken many customers to track days with there gtr's and they consistently put up times close to or better than much more experienced drivers in other cars. you still have to break properly and hit your apex but the gtr makes it easier to do it, you take a bad line and try to force a correction the gtr makes it easier, the other big thing is the throttle and the car rotating, my m6 i gotta baby the bag pedal in 2nd out of a turn, in the gtr its mash and go!!!! a tenth faster here a tenth faster there, a few tenths worth of good shifting and the car will mask allot!!!

Why keep the M6? Why not get your own GTR?

PS. - which pedal is the bag pedal? I assume gas.

shadoquad 02-26-2012 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZSIZZLE (Post 1566376)
also all you have to look at is the ring times, the gtr is like number 4 out of every car on the planet that way allot less and have way more power, thats including your enzo's, carerra gt, italia, mp412c, all the hyper cars!!!! the zr1,viper, and a couple of others beat the gtr

Once again, who is setting those ring times that people love to cite?

Professional drivers, going all-out 10/10ths of their ability.

Yes, it is one indicator of a car's performance potential. But a 7.5 minute ring time can't make a scrub faster on a track.

Gauge 02-26-2012 11:11 AM

I have never driven a GTR, only read ton and tons of reviews from people who have. One of the things that is almost universal is how easy it is for a novice to get in an do amazing around a track. The electronics in that car are just so dang good.

I'm not even thinking about the HP difference. I will, of course, yield to the experts here. Just tossing in my 2 cents.

Nick911sc 02-26-2012 11:22 AM

My father has a GT-R that I've driven on multiple occasions. I will admit that a novice driver will be able to do decent in it. But, the car will not figure out weight distribution in and out of corners, proper lines etc. (which have all been mentioned in the thread). But that's not to say it will make the car easier to drive. It takes a truly good driver to use all the technological gadgets in the GT-R to their advantage.

Lemers 02-26-2012 11:34 AM

The GTR goes beyond Simple HP numbers. It's like setting a race video game on easy. Can it be beat? yes. Here's what I can tell you the same driver does laps in a GTR then in a Z. I'm betting on the GTR laps being faster.

ZSIZZLE 02-27-2012 08:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mt Tam I am (Post 1566382)
Why keep the M6? Why not get your own GTR?

PS. - which pedal is the bag pedal? I assume gas.

As much as the Gtr capabilities blow me away, for my personal taste its not what i like. I dont like awd because it takes some of the thrill away from driving and i dont like the dct even though i know its faster because it feels like an automatic. Now if i was out to win races and break records the gtr would def be my weapon of choice. But for what i wanna enjoy on the street or track give me rwd anx a stick all day long.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 12:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2