Help deciding on second car (daily)

kholy

So I have my 2009 Nissan 370z PW Sport Touring... which I love - duh

I also have a 2005 Audi A4 Quattro 1.8T with a k04 turbo and APR tune... really like this car too. However, this car seems to break every month and I spend so much money fixing/keeping up with it that I've decided its time to part ways. I will be listing it for sale and hopefully I can get roughly 4-5k for it.

So my question is what are good second daily driver cars. To help, here is a list of things i'd like to do with it

1) I kayak so I need a way to transport these (currently have roof racks for Audi)
2) looking at possibly getting a jetski... possibly
3) Something decent on gas millage that i can take on road trips if needed.
4) I either like the big ol truck feel or the small sportier car feel
5) BE GOOD IN SNOW (I live in NE Ohio and we get a ton of snow!)

1 car that i was looking at was a newer civic si sedan. i could get roof racks for this, plus good gas millage and has plenty of room for passengers.

any suggestions are welcome

__________________
2009 Pearl White 370z Sport Touring Edition