Sound proofing experiment on the 370Z

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 12:11 PM

So I figured since I didn't have much going on this long weekend I'd do a sound proofing project on the Z to see if it makes a difference.

My goal was to get the most gains without going crazy and tearing the entire interior out or using 30+lbs of sound insulation.
I went with my left over Dynamat and Frost king which you can source at the local home depot (2 of which didn't have it, FML) at 18.99 a roll.

A few comments to those that are thinking about frost king.

1. It isn't all that cheap. 18.99 gets you ~15 sq feet so about 1/2 the price of dynamat but given the way the material feels etc it may not be worth while.
2. It is very light 1/4 of the weight of dynamat, and I am not sure the sound insulation properties of this material by itself are good because they lack mass/density etc, but since I bought it I decided to use it.
3. It does have a slight smell on the glue layer, once you apply it it goes away (since it isn't exposed) but ... it could come back, I wouldn't use rolls of this **** in the car since it will likely smell. Dynamat is pretty much odor free.

I pulled apart the trunk of my Z which was surprisingly easy/quick. My first try took me about 30 min, if I was to pull it apart again, I can likely do it in 15 min or less. No broken clips or anything.

My strategy was to supplement factory sound deadening and add to flimsy/high noise areas. I put dynamat down as a baselayer, and put frost king on top since dynamat is the heavier more dense product.

I used about 10sq feet of dynamat ~4lbs. And I used about 10sq feet of Frost king ~1-2lbs. Total of 5lbs.

Overall the results were somewhat disappointing same as my golf where I did my entire trunk with dynamat. The car does seem a bit quieter but bad roads are still really shitty.

I took 3 separate measurements all at around 65-70mph on the same stretches of road.

Bad pavement
82-83 after 80-81
ok pavement
75-76 after 73-74
Good pavement
72-73 after 70-71

Overall I'd say it cut about 2-3 db out at best. Is it noticeable, yes... slightly. I was hoping for a reduction of 5-6db which would have been good. I do not think adding any more sound insulation makes any sense. I addressed all the key areas and anything incremental would be simply chasing a 10% improvement by adding 90% more weight.

I believe the next best thing to do would be to use thicker carpet type insulation as most OEMs. But that presents a lot of other challenges that I wasn't willing to tackle.

Here are some pics

Trunk plastics pulled (not the factory sound deadening was really thin and comparable to dynamat)

SouthArk370Z · 09-08-2015, 01:13 PM

Put more sound-deadening material on the shock towers, the reinforcement between them, and the wheel wells. Those are the noisiest areas.

To do a good job, you have to cover just about everything. The padding/carpet (plus the spare) damps a lot of the noise from the spare tire well, so skimp there if need be.

Some members have reported that doing the doors makes a big difference.

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 01:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SouthArk370Z

Put more sound-deadening material on the shock towers, the reinforcement between them, and the wheel wells. Those are the noisiest areas.

To do a good job, you have to cover just about everything. The padding/carpet (plus the spare) damps a lot of the noise from the spare tire well, so skimp there if need be.

Some members have reported that doing the doors makes a big difference.

There are 3 layers of sound insulation on the wheel wells.

Factory
+Dynamat
+Frost king

I don't think adding more will do anything. The tower connecting the shock braces doesn't seem to be a source of noise it isn't close to the tires etc.

But thanks for the tips!

Covering the entire trunk is silly, that is not the right way of insulating, I did that on another car and it was quite pointless. I decided to go a more strategic route this time around.

Chuck33079 · 09-08-2015, 02:18 PM

What made the biggest difference for me was a layer of closed cell foam over the deadening material.

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 02:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck33079

What made the biggest difference for me was a layer of closed cell foam over the deadening material.

What is the brand of product that you used? and how thick is it?
Have you done any DB measurements ?
Frost king is CCF.

mishuko · 09-08-2015, 02:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370bluez

So I figured since I didn't have much going on this long weekend I'd do a sound proofing project on the Z to see if it makes a difference.

My goal was to get the most gains without going crazy and tearing the entire interior out or using 30+lbs of sound insulation.
I went with my left over Dynamat and Frost king which you can source at the local home depot (2 of which didn't have it, FML) at 18.99 a roll.

A few comments to those that are thinking about frost king.

1. It isn't all that cheap. 18.99 gets you ~15 sq feet so about 1/2 the price of dynamat but given the way the material feels etc it may not be worth while.
2. It is very light 1/4 of the weight of dynamat, and I am not sure the sound insulation properties of this material by itself are good because they lack mass/density etc, but since I bought it I decided to use it.
3. It does have a slight smell on the glue layer, once you apply it it goes away (since it isn't exposed) but ... it could come back, I wouldn't use rolls of this **** in the car since it will likely smell. Dynamat is pretty much odor free.

I pulled apart the trunk of my Z which was surprisingly easy/quick. My first try took me about 30 min, if I was to pull it apart again, I can likely do it in 15 min or less. No broken clips or anything.

My strategy was to supplement factory sound deadening and add to flimsy/high noise areas. I put dynamat down as a baselayer, and put frost king on top since dynamat is the heavier more dense product.

I used about 10sq feet of dynamat ~4lbs. And I used about 10sq feet of Frost king ~1-2lbs. Total of 5lbs.

Overall the results were somewhat disappointing same as my golf where I did my entire trunk with dynamat. The car does seem a bit quieter but bad roads are still really shitty.

I took 3 separate measurements all at around 65-70mph on the same stretches of road.

Bad pavement
82-83 after 80-81
ok pavement
75-76 after 73-74
Good pavement
72-73 after 70-71

Overall I'd say it cut about 2-3 db out at best. Is it noticeable, yes... slightly. I was hoping for a reduction of 5-6db which would have been good. I do not think adding any more sound insulation makes any sense. I addressed all the key areas and anything incremental would be simply chasing a 10% improvement by adding 90% more weight.

I believe the next best thing to do would be to use thicker carpet type insulation as most OEMs. But that presents a lot of other challenges that I wasn't willing to tackle.

Here are some pics

Trunk plastics pulled (not the factory sound deadening was really thin and comparable to dynamat)

( Click to show/hide )

as Ark said you need to get the towers both sides and the centre piece as well. i'd also try and get into the wheel well as deep as you can get it. also the inner side of the trunk is nice and flat but has a big hollow noise.

i think you will get closer to the 5db reduction mark if you did a single layer over the entire thing and a double layer over the wheel wells but i can't back that up with tests.

the one thing to remember though is the dynamat/hushmat will not sound proof, it will only reduce the noise levels a little bit. my biggest notice is the road noise from the tires + the rock 'pings' from the underside. if you want to really reduce the noise you need to go the whole 9 yards.

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mishuko

as Ark said you need to get the towers both sides and the centre piece as well. i'd also try and get into the wheel well as deep as you can get it. also the inner side of the trunk is nice and flat but has a big hollow noise.

i think you will get closer to the 5db reduction mark if you did a single layer over the entire thing and a double layer over the wheel wells but i can't back that up with tests.

the one thing to remember though is the dynamat/hushmat will not sound proof, it will only reduce the noise levels a little bit. my biggest notice is the road noise from the tires + the rock 'pings' from the underside. if you want to really reduce the noise you need to go the whole 9 yards.

The shock towers were solid metal and not paper thin 1/16" of an inch like the wheel wells and the bottom of the trunk. I got the wheel wells with two layers on the front and the back. On top of the factory material as well as some surrounding areas...

I'd like to see if someone actually got measurements of sound reductions. It is easy enough to go back and add more, but I don't want to waste time and add unnecessary weight. Covering the entire trunk etc is not wise just for the sake of covering it doesn't make sense.

mishuko · 09-08-2015, 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370bluez

The shock towers were solid metal and not paper thin 1/16" of an inch like the wheel wells and the bottom of the trunk. I got the wheel wells with two layers on the front and the back. On top of the factory material as well as some surrounding areas...

I'd like to see if someone actually got measurements of sound reductions. It is easy enough to go back and add more, but I don't want to waste time and add unnecessary weight. Covering the entire trunk etc is not wise just for the sake of covering it doesn't make sense.

to be fair you should have hit every piece of metal in your rear hatch so you didn't have to go back. all the metal parts will vibrate and send out the sound.

the dampening material adds mass to reduce vibrations and dampens the sound a bit. i think you would have hit your 5-db target if you did the entire hatch instead of portions but that's me speculating.

i'd suggest searching the audio section... tons of good material there to kill some time reading and learning

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 03:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mishuko

to be fair you should have hit every piece of metal in your rear hatch so you didn't have to go back. all the metal parts will vibrate and send out the sound.

the dampening material adds mass to reduce vibrations and dampens the sound a bit. i think you would have hit your 5-db target if you did the entire hatch instead of portions but that's me speculating.

i'd suggest searching the audio section... tons of good material there to kill some time reading and learning

I did... I looked at at least 10 threads. Most don't have any measurements behind their claims. And from what I could tell most seem disappointed even after covering the entire trunk etc.

The proper way to apply material like dynamat isn't to cover every single space of metal but only a portion preferably in the middle of a panel i went a bit overboard since these cars don't even have wheel well liners?! WTF is up with that. Which explains the whole pebble issue.

Unless you're looking for mass damping through the sheer weight of the material. But that would require 2-3 layers of dynamat which would weigh 50lbs and is completely insane.

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 03:52 PM

Anyways I was hoping to help others looking to quiet down the road noise and show them the approximate results with the route I decided to take.

As much as I searched I couldn't anyone that actually measured their before/after results.

5-6DB reduction is huge, and as I mentioned prior I haven't received that type of result on another car where I actually went full retard and covered the entire trunk since it seemed to be what most others were doing.

I received the same or better results on this car while only using 1/3 of the material!

SouthArk370Z · 09-08-2015, 04:47 PM

Door panels, bottom of spare tire well, etc are good candidates for partial coverage; suspension-connected parts, not so much. Wheel wells definitely need complete and heavy/thick coverage.

DEpointfive0 · 09-08-2015, 04:53 PM

If you don't want to add weight, add a bunch of home insulation, it absorbs sound surprisingly well. It's just super ghetto

Chuck33079 · 09-08-2015, 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370bluez

What is the brand of product that you used? and how thick is it?
Have you done any DB measurements ?
Frost king is CCF.

I used this: Ensolite IUO Peel and Stick --- 1 yard (13.875 sq ft) - RAAMaudio Inc.

I put down a full layer of deadening material, and then a full layer of foam. It made a noticeable difference in road noise, but I don't have decibel measurements.

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck33079

I used this: Ensolite IUO Peel and Stick --- 1 yard (13.875 sq ft) - RAAMaudio Inc.

I put down a full layer of deadening material, and then a full layer of foam. It made a noticeable difference in road noise, but I don't have decibel measurements.

This is good info. That product looks similar in nature to Frost King but thicker it would be a good layer on top of Dynamat. Btw does it smell?

370bluez · 09-08-2015, 05:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DEpointfive0

If you don't want to add weight, add a bunch of home insulation, it absorbs sound surprisingly well. It's just super ghetto

Makes sense. OEMs use similar products underneath carpets.

09-08-2015, 12:11 PM	#1 (permalink)
370bluez Base Member Join Date: Apr 2015 Location: Kali Posts: 54 Drives: 12 370z Rep Power: 11	Sound proofing experiment on the 370Z So I figured since I didn't have much going on this long weekend I'd do a sound proofing project on the Z to see if it makes a difference. My goal was to get the most gains without going crazy and tearing the entire interior out or using 30+lbs of sound insulation. I went with my left over Dynamat and Frost king which you can source at the local home depot (2 of which didn't have it, FML) at 18.99 a roll. A few comments to those that are thinking about frost king. 1. It isn't all that cheap. 18.99 gets you ~15 sq feet so about 1/2 the price of dynamat but given the way the material feels etc it may not be worth while. 2. It is very light 1/4 of the weight of dynamat, and I am not sure the sound insulation properties of this material by itself are good because they lack mass/density etc, but since I bought it I decided to use it. 3. It does have a slight smell on the glue layer, once you apply it it goes away (since it isn't exposed) but ... it could come back, I wouldn't use rolls of this **** in the car since it will likely smell. Dynamat is pretty much odor free. I pulled apart the trunk of my Z which was surprisingly easy/quick. My first try took me about 30 min, if I was to pull it apart again, I can likely do it in 15 min or less. No broken clips or anything. My strategy was to supplement factory sound deadening and add to flimsy/high noise areas. I put dynamat down as a baselayer, and put frost king on top since dynamat is the heavier more dense product. I used about 10sq feet of dynamat ~4lbs. And I used about 10sq feet of Frost king ~1-2lbs. Total of 5lbs. Overall the results were somewhat disappointing same as my golf where I did my entire trunk with dynamat. The car does seem a bit quieter but bad roads are still really shitty. I took 3 separate measurements all at around 65-70mph on the same stretches of road. Bad pavement 82-83 after 80-81 ok pavement 75-76 after 73-74 Good pavement 72-73 after 70-71 Overall I'd say it cut about 2-3 db out at best. Is it noticeable, yes... slightly. I was hoping for a reduction of 5-6db which would have been good. I do not think adding any more sound insulation makes any sense. I addressed all the key areas and anything incremental would be simply chasing a 10% improvement by adding 90% more weight. I believe the next best thing to do would be to use thicker carpet type insulation as most OEMs. But that presents a lot of other challenges that I wasn't willing to tackle. Here are some pics Trunk plastics pulled (not the factory sound deadening was really thin and comparable to dynamat)

09-08-2015, 01:13 PM	#2 (permalink)
SouthArk370Z Premium Member Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: South Arkansas Posts: 8,435 Drives: 2014 Challenger Rep Power: 324198	Put more sound-deadening material on the shock towers, the reinforcement between them, and the wheel wells. Those are the noisiest areas. To do a good job, you have to cover just about everything. The padding/carpet (plus the spare) damps a lot of the noise from the spare tire well, so skimp there if need be. Some members have reported that doing the doors makes a big difference. kenchan and mishuko like this. __________________ Steering Lock Links - Search The370Z Bookmarklet - FSM @ NICOclub Mankind has progressed past the need for war but we haven't evolved that far. - NachoMahma

09-08-2015, 02:18 PM	#4 (permalink)
Chuck33079 A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Nov 2011 Location: Houston Posts: 12,265 Drives: 2011 370ztt Rep Power: 29539	What made the biggest difference for me was a layer of closed cell foam over the deadening material. __________________ 2011 MB Touring-Sport-6sp-Nav/GTM TT/FI TT TDX/JTran/Kosmic/Eibach/Hotchkis/SPC/CSF/RPS/SoThatsWhereAllMyMoneyWent

09-08-2015, 04:47 PM	#11 (permalink)
SouthArk370Z Premium Member Join Date: Nov 2010 Location: South Arkansas Posts: 8,435 Drives: 2014 Challenger Rep Power: 324198	Door panels, bottom of spare tire well, etc are good candidates for partial coverage; suspension-connected parts, not so much. Wheel wells definitely need complete and heavy/thick coverage. __________________ Steering Lock Links - Search The370Z Bookmarklet - FSM @ NICOclub Mankind has progressed past the need for war but we haven't evolved that far. - NachoMahma

09-08-2015, 04:53 PM	#12 (permalink)
DEpointfive0 A True Z Fanatic Join Date: Jan 2012 Location: SoCal Posts: 14,824 Drives: a lot Rep Power: 17152	If you don't want to add weight, add a bunch of home insulation, it absorbs sound surprisingly well. It's just super ghetto __________________ Do YOU want to know what/where I got my username from? ( Click to show/hide ) NSFW due to language:

09-08-2015, 03:52 PM	#10 (permalink)
370bluez Base Member Join Date: Apr 2015 Location: Kali Posts: 54 Drives: 12 370z Rep Power: 11	Anyways I was hoping to help others looking to quiet down the road noise and show them the approximate results with the route I decided to take. As much as I searched I couldn't anyone that actually measured their before/after results. 5-6DB reduction is huge, and as I mentioned prior I haven't received that type of result on another car where I actually went full retard and covered the entire trunk since it seemed to be what most others were doing. I received the same or better results on this car while only using 1/3 of the material!

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
Sound Proofing	Turfgod	Audio & Video	18	08-19-2015 10:16 PM
RE-71R experiment?	Z1NONLY	Track / Autocross / Drifting / Dragstrip	37	07-10-2015 02:36 AM
Houston sound proofing	diala4asian	Texas	1	08-22-2014 02:41 PM
Need someone to do this experiment	RiCharlie	Photography	16	08-20-2013 10:50 AM
Sound Proofing	Figtuna	Audio & Video	29	12-03-2011 04:02 PM