if his price does include dest fee then he's already giving it to you for $240 under invoice. dest fee is $720 (if i remember) but the difference between your invoice and his is only $482.
DO IT!!!

He got back to me with this:

Vehicle Base price plus Freight - $33,817

The options are as follows:

Floor mats - $89
Navigation - $1,605
Splash Gaurds - $165
Sport Package - $2,602

Total = $38,278

Seems like a pretty solid price to me, yes? Now I'm deciding if I should pull the trigger on it. I'm driving an 05 Scion tC which has zero issues with it. I could probably drive it for ten more years without a problem. But I've wanted the 370z since last year before it even came out. Hmm......

So did you end up buying it?

No... I told myself to wait for the 2010s to come out and see how much the price drops. But now I'm reconsidering again. Can't make up my mind. The dealership still has 3 in my color and model so there's no pressure to rush

I see. I'll bet you could get a better deal on the 09 though. And since the changes are really minimal on the 2010, I'd go with the 09 if I were you and just enjoy it.