Nismo or 911
 

For probably the last year I have been saving up and getting ready to purchase, after tons of research on both cars. It really comes down to either a 2011 Nismo or like a 05/06 911. The only thing holding me back is the fear that the porsche will be to expensive to maintain. I absolutely love the way the Nismo looks but still hanging on to that childhood dream of owning a porsche. What do you all think? Great Forum by the way!

I'd go with the Nismo, newer and cheaper to maintain

911...if you don't you'll be still holding onto the dream in your 70's with a walker. the Nismo isn't going anywhere. and welcome to the family. aaarrrgggghhhh my phone won't let me captialize....crap.

911 is older and will be expensive to maintain without warranty, but it is the better car. Faster, more refined, and more prestigious.

The Z is the better value proposition though.

Yeah, these are all the things I've been going back and forth on...

If you get a 997, try to find an '06 or newer due to the updated IMS bearing. I've seen a few CPO 997 models for $43-45k, but I'd prefer a 997S...which go for about $5-7k more in comparable condition to a base.

Yeah, have read quite a bit on the IMS. Between clutch,tires, etc. and having to worry about getting a PPI before buying, it's like damn what the hell am I committing too..

Yeah. I was looking into 997S and 996TTS, but decided to stick it out with my car. Good luck on your search...they are amazing cars! My 2 best friends have a modded 996TT with the x50 package and the other has a highly modded 997TT. The looks are subjective, but they are great all around cars.

Are you looking for a weekend car or a dd?

I would do the Nismo for a DD, but if you're looking for a toy car then go with the Porsche.

depending on how old you are, unless you're like 70 or something with one foot in the coffin, get the nismo cause im thinking you still have a while to achieve your ultimate goal without killing yourself for maintenance costs in the mean time.

Go for your dreams!!! You worked and waited this long you deserve it.
Life is short. Get the 911...:tup:

You guys aren't making this easy....every other post tells me to go in the opposite direction. I do love the look of the nismo.

Buy Both! I did. :)

Boss 302

911s really aren't that expensive to maintain. I know several porsche mechanics and not only is the maintenance comparable to most other cars, but they often don't need a lot of work since they're so well engineered.

I'd take the 911! Nismos are great, but 911s are a polished Z with better road feel.

Sorry for being a devils advocate.
Yes its costly to maintain a Porsche but they are bullet proof cars.
Man if you have seen them run the 24 hrs LeMans and 12hrs at Sebring you'll get amazed how this cars can take the beating. Don't know if any of the 911's Gt3 DNF.

If i can afford a 911 now I'll jump on it like a heart beat. But that's me.
You know what's best for you. Either way they are good cars to have.

See my car knocking on Heavens doors??? hahaha

I would go for a Nismo.
If you make good $$$, it does not matter which one you choose. GL :tup:

Porches make great daily drivers as well. I love the Z as well, so it's a toss up:stirthepot:

:iagree:

Get a Nismo, enjoy it, and work towards owning a new 911 one day.

the 911 in a heartbeat, not even close.

Depends where you live. Here in the Midwest, it would not be the best...not that the Nismo is much better.

Let's see... What's the person above me has suggested...

Okay, go with the Nismo.:tup:

I have always wanted a 2001 911 Turbo. I make the money. I could own one. But I bought a Z. Why? Because a car is what you make it. I don't need or want a Porsche to take spirited runs through the woods. The Z, after only a couple of easy mods will do everything I want it too and then some. It will be difficult to even push it to its limit outside of the track. And I'm not even talking a Nismo. Just a plain 'ole touring base model. And hell, I've met guys that gave up far more expensive cars to get into a Z and never looked back. Don't think of it as if you owned a Z, it wouldn't be expensive enough or have the name stamped on it that would make you proud to own it. And I think that is the part that gets everyone.

In the end, it is what tugs at you more. If you have the means to own either, I would choose what draws you more. If not, everytime you pass one you'll say "Damn, I almost bought that!" Then you'll think of some BS reason to backup your decision to own one or the other that will make you sleep better at night.

I say get the Z. The Japanese can make some serious sports cars. ;) And besides! Why the hell would you get a Porsche before a GTR anyway?! You can get a 2010 for $65k!!! :D

Good luck with your decision. Hope whatever you get you will be proud and not look back.

Nismo because the cost to maintenance a Porsche will probably be 4 times more.

Before buying the 370z I had a Mercedes, and oil change on the C320 cost 3 times more than that of the 370z. I would have to think oil change on a Porsche 911 has to cost a lot more than a MB C320.

But if money is no object then go for the 911. GL with your decision :)

To be honest, while your young(I assume), get the nismo while you can and save money for a NEW 911 turbo later. You don't wanna do the backwards unless you decide to pass up the Nismo. I don't see many older fellas drove Nismo on the road they usually rock the Porsche. You still have plenty of time to get a Porsche.:tup:

I vote Nismo. Seriously fun car to drive. There's something special about being the first owner of a car as well. You know everything this car has been through with no hidden surprises. I'm sure most Porches are well taken care of by their original owners, but who knows, right? :twocents:

OP, if you are asking this question in a Z forum, you know you already want the 911 but you are trying to find out a good reason not to get it. ;)

You won't go wrong if you take a good test drive and buy the one that feels the best to you. Also, test drive at more than one dealer of each. That way you get a chance to check various options that you may like and get some competitive prices. Watch the dealers as they often start with similar prices, hoping to land a sucker. Also, dealers in various cities are sometimes located in different regions with a difference in price. Most importantly, ask around about the service you can expect from each. If I could afford both and had the opportunity to own both, I would probably still drive my z... I've had it for almost a year and I still love driving it everyday...... It's like fun ride everyday and sometimes I just can't wait to get off work and drive home in it lol

A 911 late 90's is a good looking car. The Nismo is newer and with power as well. Go with whichever makes you happy. I love the Nismo, never had an opportunity to own a late model Porsche, so I can't say anything about them but they look good as well. Follow your dreams, be happy and don't spend so much in repairs.

Are you looking at a 2011 Nismo serial # 191? I just traded my Nismo.... a big sacrifice I had to do for the family

Don't buy anything. Leave your money in the bank and keep saving till you hit $108,000 and can afford a 911. Then you can ask yourself. Porsche 911 or down payment on a 911 turbo?

But if you're gonna buy right now. The Nismo makes more sense.

911 will be a better choice imo. quieter interior. maintainence is not that bad (idk where people are getting that from) and it will be worth more in 5 years in case u wanna sell it

Sorry, too lazy to verify. But you're referring to a 996 911, correct? Not really my favorite Porsche but still superior than a Nismo--especially a Carrera S.

get a maxima. they are just as fast.

I went with the 911 but im not to fond of the year (go newer). Im also hoping its not a plain jane 911. If so go Nismo.

I work one of the largest Porsche dealers in the world (sales). Let me know if I can help with anything... I drive a 2012 Nismo myself and obvsiouly drive every form of a 911 almost daily..

First of all, what model 911?

1. Test drive both. You may find that the Nismo is just a bit rough for you as a DD. Power aside, you'll almost certainly find the 911 to be a smoother ride that makes you love it. It'll be supple and happy to do whatever. Also, that engine behind your ears? Yeah, nice.

2. If you find the right 911 at a good price in good condition and with all the options you really want, it's hard to say don't jump on that chance.

3. As someone said, the Nismo isn't going anywhere. You could always re-flip the Porsche probably easier than the Nismo. (Just a guess on my part, not an experience.)

For me, personally, I'd rather get what I truly want. If I truly wanted the 911 as a dream and have the chance, if I choose the Nismo, I'll always wish I had jumped on that chance for the 911. Just like the girl back in school... You may find that you made the wrong decision and should have done the Nismo, but at least you'll have satisfied your dream and you won't really feel that bad about the decision.

I take it by your ownership choice you prefer the Nismo? :) Just curious on any driving reasons for that, or just financial?

A Maxima with a CAI > a 911, since it can haul more people and gets better MPG.











However, I voted 911, well, because I'm partial to Porsche. Though, it depends on the model. If I could afford it, a '98 993 911 Turbo would be my choice. I don't mind the 996 models, but would stray away from a Carrera unless it was a 4S.

It's a tough call honestly. I just grabbed this 2012 sport, was considering older 911 as option myself. Dad has a 2006/8? 911 S

I think you would be happy with either one. I would say get the nismo-but I'm partial.