BMW 335i VS. INFINITI G37S

[bossman]

these two have been compared since their announcements.. c&d says bimmer is better cuz of handling but then again they do worship bmw.. motortrend says G is better due to value and reliability.. I wanna know your take on it.

judging criteria = acceleration, handling, reliability, LOOKS, value, luxury, class, curb appeal, and sex appeal

[Crash]

Personally, I don't like the looks for the Non-M BMWs (except for the Z4 Coupes. Those are just awesome in all trims.)

If I were buying a luxury car and the handling was HARDLY a difference between the two, it would be nothing I care about. I'm buying a luxury car, not a track car. I don't plan on doing 100 MPH through the canyons in my luxury car. If I was, I'd be upgrading the suspension anyway.

Nissan is FAR more reliable than BMW. Hands down. I've had a G35 and M35 and neither of them have been in the shop for anything other than oil changes. I've had the M for 3 years and had the G for 2 years.

Nissan wins in Value. You're not paying for the name BMW, and when the car goes out of warranty, the parts are cheaper than BMW's.

I think the BMW wins in Luxury. It's been a year or so since I've been in one, but I remember liking the creature comforts in the BMW more. Same options, but done very well in the BMW.

BMW's name comes with it's own class. I've heard girls say "I won't date a guy that doesn't drive a Bimmer." <-- Sad but true. Freaking hussies.

Curb appeal is a draw for me. I look at the two cars and I think the same thing about both of them. $50K car. Fit and finish. And both very refined.

BMW's going to get you laid, but you'll be happier with a better built car, unless you're just trying to get laid.

[Namir]

Oh lord not this again.

Probably of the most beat to death comparison of the last few years. E90post, myG37, ClubLexus, etc etc. its on every forum.

My take, get whatever car you like more: They are both great cars.

[gettingaZ]

Originally Posted by Namir

Oh lord not this again.

Probably of the most beat to death comparison of the last few years. E90post, myG37, ClubLexus, etc etc. its on every forum.

My take, get whatever car you like more: They are both great cars.

IMO the Bimmer is plain and boring. When you buy a BMW you are being ripped off and bent over without lube. While the BMW may ride good and handle, thats pretty much all they do. Unless you get an M model and you better bring your own lube for that one! IMO like the above poster the only decent looking ones are the M versions but they are WAY overpriced!

The Infiniti on the other hand looks great, handles great (for the street), is quick and has a great interior. Hands down Infiniti!

[klubbheads]

Originally Posted by Namir

Oh lord not this again.

Probably of the most beat to death comparison of the last few years. E90post, myG37, ClubLexus, etc etc. its on every forum.

My take, get whatever car you like more: They are both great cars.

Well said

Originally Posted by gettingaZ

IMO the Bimmer is plain and boring. When you buy a BMW you are being ripped off and bent over without lube. While the BMW may ride good and handle, thats pretty much all they do. Unless you get an M model and you better bring your own lube for that one! IMO like the above poster the only decent looking ones are the M versions but they are WAY overpriced!

The Infiniti on the other hand looks great, handles great (for the street), is quick and has a great interior. Hands down Infiniti!

Plain and boring?
Over priced?

[!xoible]

Originally Posted by bossman

these two have been compared since their announcements.. c&d says bimmer is better cuz of handling but then again they do worship bmw.. motortrend says G is better due to value and reliability.. I wanna know your take on it.

judging criteria = acceleration, handling, reliability, LOOKS, value, luxury, class, curb appeal, and sex appeal

i have owned both cars so i can chime in:
1. acceleration there's no comparison. The throttle and turbo response on the 335 is epic, chipped or not! The G37 even if it's fast (altho definitely not faster than 335) still "feels" slow coz it needs to build up the torque
2. handling: the G37 handles pretty well but i would say if the 335 gets 10 points, the G37 gets 8. Plus the 335 comes with Michelin PS2's which are much gummier and grippy than bridgeSTONE.
3. reliability: i am unaware of any G37 issues, but i know one very common issue with 335 which is the fuel pump frequent failures
4. stock vs. stock i guess it's matter of preference. i was kinda disappointed with the G's new look after the G35 (which was awesome IMHO). the BMW lacks a few things in the front. but the aero lip for 300 bucks remedies that very nicely. the G37 looks bulky, but i cannot live with either of them just stock. G37 needs some serious spacers, the butt is ridiculously SC430ish, front is just not special.
The 335 can look boring too... so u need some wheels, drop, aero lip and ur good. this is all subjective, but the attention i got in the 335 >>> the one in G37
5. value as in per buck? i dont have much to say about that. u get what you pay for
6. the rest is all redundant lol

[CrownR426]

I like what Infiniti did with the G37S.
They got my vote in this.

[msl82]

In my opinion, it is very unfair to compare BMW 335 to Inifity G37S.

BMW 335 coupe starts at $42,000 and can go up to +50,000

I think its more appropriate to compare BMW 328, which starts at $37,000 with 230 HP and 200 TQ.

Infinity G37 starts at $37,000 with 330HP and 270 TQ.


Infinity G37 vs BMW 328....LOL no comparison.

Always, it has been my personal opinion that, unless its BMW M class, other BMW lineups are overpriced, or you can get better cars for that money.

[!xoible]

actually the 328 is still pretty nice. might not do the 1/4 mile, but still handles better, etc. i wouldnt say "no comparison"

but then if the G37 was priced as much as the 335 then there would be a "LOL no comparison" they only way G37 can compete is by being cheap. not everyone likes "cheap"

[msl82]

Originally Posted by !xoible

actually the 328 is still pretty nice. might not do the 1/4 mile, but still handles better, etc. i wouldnt say "no comparison"

but then if the G37 was priced as much as the 335 then there would be a "LOL no comparison" they only way G37 can compete is by being cheap. not everyone likes "cheap"

LOL, typical BMW fanboy response.

So stuck up with BMW badge, that they will regard all other non-BMW cars as piece of ****, no matter how good that car is for its price.

[!xoible]

Originally Posted by msl82

LOL, typical BMW fanboy response.

So stuck up with BMW badge, that they will regard all other non-BMW cars as piece of ****, no matter how good that car is for its price.

im not anything fanboy, im on a Z forum wanting to buy a Z and i owned more than one infiniti before my BMW's. you are missing my argument. say if the 370Z was priced almost as much as Cayman S the Z will have a harder time competing in the market, do you not agree? i know you guys here all love the Z and probably do not give any credit to the "bland lame mainstream with stupid interior" cayman S, but let's get real!

if the G37 was priced as high as the 3er you would see much less of it on the street. people who can afford the 3er are not likely to ditch the 3er for the G37.

i am not saying it's a piece of ****, but the price is a huge part of what makes the G compete. i give credit where it's due, i've had both cars and drove both to their limits!

[shumby]

Originally Posted by !xoible

if the G37 was priced as high as the 3er you would see much less of it on the street. people who can afford the 3er are not likely to ditch the 3er for the G37.

!

i have no issues affording a 335i I liked the G better and it is not something everyone drives. I did consider the M3 however but the wife still did not like the styling so cuz she controls the fun hole she won. however once I invest the difference in the cost between the G and the 335 in tt's for the G good luck having the 335 keep up with me.

[shumby]

i don't htink the G37 is cheap. it is less $ then the 335i but you can compair and it holds it own quite nicely.

[!xoible]

lol i didnt mean it as in cheap like cheap, but affordable... but in certain aspects yes u do get what you pay for

[Epik]

Poor G37.

Can't quite dethrone the 335i and now gets pushed aside by the Hyundai Genesis Coupe lol.