Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Forced Induction (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/)
-   -   Stillen supercharger long term reports (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/66333-stillen-supercharger-long-term-reports.html)

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 01:44 PM

Call these guys and order some straighteners cut to the diameter of the inlet pipes. Install (with epoxy) directly before the MAFs. That flutter will go away.

Honeycomb for MAF

Osiris 02-19-2013 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sh0velMan (Post 2173860)
Call these guys and order some straighteners cut to the diameter of the inlet pipes. Install (with epoxy) directly before the MAFs. That flutter will go away.

Honeycomb for MAF

oh wow, you might just be on to something there!! And it's cheap...now just to figure out the thickness to use???

kellyefields 02-19-2013 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173875)
oh wow, you might just be on to something there!! And it's cheap...now just to figure out the thickness to use???

the honeycomb may be the ticket to get the air going through the tubes right but I still believe blocking direct air especially to the lower filter is the real fix otherwise you will always have the lower MAF reading higher than the upper even though it will always be the same going into the engine.

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 01:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173875)
oh wow, you might just be on to something there!! And it's cheap...now just to figure out the thickness to use???

Guys in blow-through setups like to use the higher ratios, but I think 5:1 should be fine for what you guys are trying to do.

I plan on putting some 4:1 or 5:1's in my intakes when I rebuild them. Should clean up the idle.

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kellyefields (Post 2173892)
the honeycomb may be the ticket to get the air going through the tubes right but I still believe blocking direct air especially to the lower filter is the real fix otherwise you will always have the lower MAF reading higher than the upper even though it will always be the same going into the engine.

IAT sensor is only utilized on one bank anyway, and the S/C itself equalizes the real temps... So yeah. Non-issue.

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 02:00 PM

Oh, and you'll probably need a re-tune, because likely your tuner has used fuel compensation to get around weird readings from your MAF sensors, so they'll need to kinda start over once you stabilize MAF response.

Osiris 02-19-2013 02:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sh0velMan (Post 2173909)
Oh, and you'll probably need a re-tune, because likely your tuner has used fuel compensation to get around weird readings from your MAF sensors, so they'll need to kinda start over once you stabilize MAF response.

Actually, when we were doing some data logging....he mentioned that all the AFR settings were correct, it just gets all wacky when its fluctuating up and down. But when it is not fluctuating, all settings are where they need to be. Now i just need to measure the inlets....ugh, have to take off bumper :(

irondoc 02-19-2013 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sh0velMan (Post 2173900)
IAT sensor is only utilized on one bank anyway, and the S/C itself equalizes the real temps... So yeah. Non-issue.

I have to wonder if this is correct. What I have been told by my tuner and by Stillen is that no matter that the airflow is completely changed/stabilized by the tubine before it hits the TBA, the engine perceives a problem at the MAF and is trying to adjust air/fuel balance to solve a problem that is only a matter of perception (rather than reality).

Sounds like a philosophical/existential debate!

But I agree that honeycombs or extended intake tubes would probably help. I prefer the Honeycomb option theoretically if only because the added weight at the nose of this already nose heavy car would be less.
BTW I am currently in communication with Stillen on this issue and they are working on it as we speak.

irondoc 02-19-2013 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173959)
Actually, when we were doing some data logging....he mentioned that all the AFR settings were correct, it just gets all wacky when its fluctuating up and down. But when it is not fluctuating, all settings are where they need to be. Now i just need to measure the inlets....ugh, have to take off bumper :(

Gotta take off the d*mn bumper to make any changes anyway. Please post your tube ID/OD dimensions when you have them.

Osiris 02-19-2013 02:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2173970)
Gotta take off the d*mn bumper to make any changes anyway. Please post your tube ID/OD dimensions when you have them.

i'm terrible with acronyms...ID/OD? But yes, i'll post them...just not sure when i'll get around to taking bumper off.

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2173962)
I have to wonder if this is correct. What I have been told by my tuner and by Stillen is that no matter that the airflow is completely changed/stabilized by the tubine before it hits the TBA, the engine perceives a problem at the MAF and is trying to adjust air/fuel balance to solve a problem that is only a matter of perception (rather than reality).

Sounds like a philosophical/existential debate!

But I agree that honeycombs or extended intake tubes would probably help. I prefer the Honeycomb option theoretically if only because the added weight at the nose of this already nose heavy car would be less.
BTW I am currently in communication with Stillen on this issue and they are working on it as we speak.

IAT is definitely used in closed loop mode, but it's only one of several factors used.

Only one bank is reported to the OBD CAN system, that can be confirmed with a hair dryer and any logging tool. That said, maybe the ECU still sees both readings and uses them. I can't say for certain.

In the end, the temperature differential between the two sensors mounted inches apart can't be so large as to matter, in a forced induction setup. And the car would soon learn around any potential issue at the time of flashing. That's what learned fuel trim is for, after all.

:)

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 02:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173972)
i'm terrible with acronyms...ID/OD? But yes, i'll post them...just not sure when i'll get around to taking bumper off.

Inside and Outside Diameter.

Sh0velMan 02-19-2013 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173959)
Actually, when we were doing some data logging....he mentioned that all the AFR settings were correct, it just gets all wacky when its fluctuating up and down. But when it is not fluctuating, all settings are where they need to be. Now i just need to measure the inlets....ugh, have to take off bumper :(

Your MAF may report different voltages after the air has been straightened, though, and those voltages may change differently through the RPM range.

That's why he would have used fuel compensation to even it out.

Or it may be identical, who can say without trying? haha

Edit:
To clarify what I mean, lets say that @ WOT you start at 1.2v around 2k RPM and by redline you're reading 4.6v.

Then you straighten out your airflow and now you're getting 0.9v at 2k RPM and by redline you're at 4.8v. Because the turbulence compressed your delta V over the rev range, and now that the turbulence isn't there, you're getting accurate flow numbers.

But because your tuner set up your fueling tables based on that 1.2v-4.6v spread, you've got inaccurate fueling data throughout the rev range. See what I mean?

(this is all theoretical, numbers picked at random)

Osiris 02-19-2013 02:30 PM

also, if you are communicating with Stillen...can you see if they have the dimensions off hand?

irondoc 02-19-2013 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sh0velMan (Post 2173980)
Inside and Outside Diameter.

Thanks for answering for me.

Nut_N_Much 02-19-2013 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2173995)
also, if you are communicating with Stillen...can you see if they have the dimensions off hand?

Okay, here it is. My SC is on the table, wiating for boost pulley.
2 Inlets on the Y:
Inside Dia 2 1/2
Outside Dia 2 7/8

Single outlet on the Y
Inside Dia 2 5/8
Outside Dia 3

Reducer Boot from Y to SC intake:
2 1/2

SC outlet:
Inside 2 3/8
Outside 2 7/8

Intake tube from SC to Throttle Bodies:
From SC side 2 5/8
From (2) throttle body side 2 1/2

Of note, the center of the MAF Mount is 2 inched from the K&N filter. If you need more let me know! Hope this helps..

elperuano 02-19-2013 09:19 PM

Lotta extra work goin on here!

irondoc 02-20-2013 07:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elperuano (Post 2174719)
Lotta extra work goin on here!

Yes, Yes, we know how you feel, gloating isn't very nice.

Sh0velMan 02-20-2013 08:13 AM

So order a couple of 63.5/64MM air straighteners, probably 5:1 or 7:1 and put them just inside the inlet pipe before the MAF's and I bet your drivability issues go away.

irondoc 02-24-2013 11:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nut_N_Much (Post 2174656)
Okay, here it is. My SC is on the table, wiating for boost pulley.
2 Inlets on the Y:
Inside Dia 2 1/2
Outside Dia 2 7/8

Single outlet on the Y
Inside Dia 2 5/8
Outside Dia 3

Reducer Boot from Y to SC intake:
2 1/2

SC outlet:
Inside 2 3/8
Outside 2 7/8

Intake tube from SC to Throttle Bodies:
From SC side 2 5/8
From (2) throttle body side 2 1/2

Of note, the center of the MAF Mount is 2 inched from the K&N filter. If you need more let me know! Hope this helps..

Thanks for the info I decided to contact saxonpc the website for the honeycomb to get their advice on the right size to order. I will let the forum know when I have a response.

irondoc 02-24-2013 03:16 PM

AEM ETI Intake System
 
1 Attachment(s)
Just noticed this photo of the AEM ETI Intake System. It has the same proximity of the MAF socket to the airfilter as in our Stillen SC kit.
Gotta wonder if any one with the ETI Intake System can comment on whether it has the same troubles as in our kit.

Osiris 02-24-2013 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2181721)
Thanks for the info I decided to contact saxonpc the website for the honeycomb to get their advice on the right size to order. I will let the forum know when I have a response.

i've already ordered a pair...64mm 3/4 inch thick. They should be arriving this week.

SS_Firehawk 02-24-2013 03:36 PM

No issues with mine AEM.

irondoc 03-02-2013 02:28 PM

Regarding my drive-ability issues as previously described. Stillen believes they have a fix based on the symptoms and the Cipher file I sent. They are working on it and say they should have a solution shortly - more later.
Osiris - let us know how the air straighteners work out.

Nut_N_Much 03-02-2013 07:24 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Someones modified his Y pipe.. Its got 2 flat plates welded into the intake side. Looks like who ever had the kit before him had issues too, and tried to fix them. I don't think he will use the air straighteners.

Man all that work pulling the front apart.. Damn..

Osiris 03-02-2013 07:32 PM

I bought my kit new, so it came like that. I just never saw it because the dealer installed it originally

Osiris 03-02-2013 08:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2193082)
Osiris - let us know how the air straighteners work out.

so, basically i couldn't install them because....well, just look at the above pic.

irondoc 03-03-2013 09:14 AM

Okay, So that must be part of Stillen's solution to the problem in addition to the shield.
I would have been seriously irritated/pissed off, as I am sure you were - I can only imagine the silent (or otherwise) stream of invective that discovery must have caused.
Unfortunately there were no available pics of the intake tube ends like the one you posted. Hopefully you can label it so an image search for "Stillen supercharger CAI" can find it.
Stillen's proposed solution has to do with air recirculation in the emissions control system. It won't help with California street legal cars but it might benefit you as you live in Florida. They are testing it now, I hope to hear from them this week.

Osiris 03-03-2013 09:28 AM

Not all of them have this....Nut_N_Much's Y pipe is completely open, no lateral fins like on mine.

irondoc 03-03-2013 11:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Osiris (Post 2193958)
Not all of them have this....Nut_N_Much's Y pipe is completely open, no lateral fins like on mine.

So...wtf?
What year did you order your kit?

irondoc 03-03-2013 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nut_N_Much (Post 2174656)
Okay, here it is. My SC is on the table, wiating for boost pulley.
2 Inlets on the Y:
Inside Dia 2 1/2
Outside Dia 2 7/8

Single outlet on the Y
Inside Dia 2 5/8
Outside Dia 3

Reducer Boot from Y to SC intake:
2 1/2

SC outlet:
Inside 2 3/8
Outside 2 7/8

Intake tube from SC to Throttle Bodies:
From SC side 2 5/8
From (2) throttle body side 2 1/2

Of note, the center of the MAF Mount is 2 inched from the K&N filter. If you need more let me know! Hope this helps..

Nut_N_Much -
So, is your kit brand new? If the kit is just out of the car for mods, what year did you order it

Osiris 03-03-2013 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2194113)
So...wtf?
What year did you order your kit?

ordered mine early 2010.

Nut_N_Much 03-03-2013 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2194123)
Nut_N_Much -
So, is your kit brand new? If the kit is just out of the car for mods, what year did you order it

Mine was used and sat around for 2 years on some guys shelf.. It is a V3 SC the older ones are V2's. My Y pip is completely open.

I have looked at some cast aluminum 8 inch tubing. I was thinking of chopping it in half and welding 4 inches to each side to extend the intake side of the Y. KellyeFields made a nice shield our of some flat sheet Aluminum, I might do that to if the factory shield isn't working. Will bring it to the Dyno.. I cut out the fins inside of the front bumper. I got nice access into the that area.

Osiris 03-03-2013 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nut_N_Much (Post 2194305)
Mine was used and sat around for 2 years on some guys shelf.. It is a V3 SC the older ones are V2's. My Y pip is completely open.

I have looked at some cast aluminum 8 inch tubing. I was thinking of chopping it in half and welding 4 inches to each side to extend the intake side of the Y. KellyeFields made a nice shield our of some flat sheet Aluminum, I might do that to if the factory shield isn't working. Will bring it to the Dyno.. I cut out the fins inside of the front bumper. I got nice access into the that area.

well, i could probably get them to you sometime next weekend if you want the honeycombs i have

Nut_N_Much 03-03-2013 02:06 PM

Matt,
Sent you PM :tiphat:

irondoc 03-03-2013 02:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nut_N_Much (Post 2194305)
Mine was used and sat around for 2 years on some guys shelf.. It is a V3 SC the older ones are V2's. My Y pip is completely open.

I have looked at some cast aluminum 8 inch tubing. I was thinking of chopping it in half and welding 4 inches to each side to extend the intake side of the Y. KellyeFields made a nice shield our of some flat sheet Aluminum, I might do that to if the factory shield isn't working. Will bring it to the Dyno.. I cut out the fins inside of the front bumper. I got nice access into the that area.

Do you intend to use the honeycombs? Even the Stillen engineer I spoke with thought it might be a good idea. Maybe Osiris will sell you his. If the Stillen engineer is right my problem may have nothing to do with the Y-pipe intake. And you may not have any issues at all. Stillen has been selling these kits for years and there are not a ton of people chiming in here.

Just thought I would mention that other than this truly minor drive-ability issue the kit truly has been awesome - totally changed the character of the car.

Nut_N_Much 03-03-2013 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by irondoc (Post 2194429)
Do you intend to use the honeycombs? Even the Stillen engineer I spoke with thought it might be a good idea. Maybe Osiris will sell you his. If the Stillen engineer is right my problem may have nothing to do with the Y-pipe intake. And you may not have any issues at all. Stillen has been selling these kits for years and there are not a ton of people chiming in here.

Just thought I would mention that other than this truly minor drive-ability issue the kit truly has been awesome - totally changed the character of the car.

I would like too, but I am lacking funds until I get some UMA Fenders sold.

dansracing 03-03-2013 07:19 PM

Well I got my kit installed last week and picked the car up on Thursday. Went on about a 500 mile round trip and the car and kit performed flawless. I dyno'd in at 413 WHP which is about what I was looking for. I instructed my tuner to set it up extra reliable.
I have plenty of clean power and the drivability is excellent. At normal cruising speeds you would never know any work had been done on the car. I cruised at speed ranges from 60 - 70 and 80 for long periods at a time. And of course slammed it down many times as well. I feel like I put the car through a pretty good series of driving conditions and she never missed a beat. Like a said, it drove flawless.
I have to give credit to J Tran Studios in Houston Texas. Ron did a spectacular install and of course, Johnny is the master of tuning our cars. Taking it back in this Saturday to change the SC oil and I should be good to for long term, except that I will be back in before long for meth injection. Mainly for engine safety reasons.
I will post some pictures tomorrow. I forgot to take them today.

dansracing 03-04-2013 05:37 PM

Here is my setup:

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8108/8...0f346485_c.jpg

http://farm9.staticflickr.com/8508/8...a0c1fd6e_c.jpg

Nixlimited 03-04-2013 07:33 PM

That's a beautiful setup!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:57 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2