Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Engine & Drivetrain (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/)
-   -   Radiator: CSF or Mishimoto? (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/70708-radiator-csf-mishimoto.html)

jcast_0089 07-09-2013 12:16 AM

hey guys, I just had my CSF Radiator and Z1 Oil cooler kit installed on my car and drove it home and parked it. When I got out and walked over to the passenger side after letting it sit for a few minutes, I noticed some water leaking from underneath my car. I think that it is the AC leaking. Is it normal for that to happen after the AC gets recharged?

Chuck33079 07-09-2013 05:52 AM

Are you sure it's not normal condensation from the ac?

ChrisSlicks 07-09-2013 06:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck33079 (Post 2396719)
Are you sure it's not normal condensation from the ac?

This. :iagree:

It is normal for the A/C to drain condensation.

ColdFire 07-10-2013 01:58 PM

This discussion is prompt at the right time, summer is starting to boil and consider a radiator would be up on my list.
question for the Turbo and SS guys, is there enough space to install big oil cooler, csf radiator and intercooler?

theDreamer 07-10-2013 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdFire (Post 2399013)
This discussion is prompt at the right time, summer is starting to boil and consider a radiator would be up on my list.
question for the Turbo and SS guys, is there enough space to install big oil cooler, csf radiator and intercooler?

Yes and no.
TT Intercooler->Oil Cooler (up to a certain size)->Radiator will work, but for the single SC guys (GTM) the space between the intercooler & radiator is to small so the oil cooler is mounted off to one side.

SS_Firehawk 07-10-2013 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ColdFire (Post 2399013)
This discussion is prompt at the right time, summer is starting to boil and consider a radiator would be up on my list.
question for the Turbo and SS guys, is there enough space to install big oil cooler, csf radiator and intercooler?

Yes there will be space... theoretically. With my build, my oil coolers have to go in front of the intercoolers. If I had an aftermarket front bumper with a larger opening, then things could be shuffled a bit to make it more effective. FYI, my car has the twin IC setup the MHI has and the crash bumper is in place. I opted for the larger and more powerful SPAL fans to help compensate the airflow deficiency. I'll see how it works when I get the car back home.

Stino 07-10-2013 04:06 PM

I stared a thread a few weeks back regarding my Mishimoto Radiator install. Thread link and post below.

Overall I feel the NEW Mishimoto Radiator for our Z is top quality and performs outstanding. The deciding factor for me was that it has 2 rows and being 40mm thick allows for more coolant.

http://www.the370z.com/diy-section-d...r-install.html
____________________________________

I installed the NEW Mishimoto Radiator over the weekend. The install was straight-forward and an easy install for you Do-It-Yourselfers. I was very impressed with the quality and that everything fit perfectly without having to modify anything on my Z.

The stock radiator core is only 13mm thick with 1 row. The Mishimoto radiator core is a massive 40mm thick with 2 rows. I don’t have any gauges to compare the temperature differences, however, I use my infrared temperature gun to gather a few reading. I saw an average of 20-30 degree decrease in temperature when comparing different areas of the radiator and engine before and after install. Also my oil temps are much lower as well. This was an unforeseen benefit and much needed living in Florida.

I posted a YouTube video and some pics below. You may find them useful if you are looking to replace your stock radiator.

Feel free to contact me if you have any questions.

Forgot to mention. Contact Luke at THMotorsports for good pricing and fast shipping. Nissan 370Z Forum - View Profile: THMotorsports

Stino

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JpGWiTWvEp4

http://www.the370z.com/members/stino...radiator06.jpg

http://www.the370z.com/members/stino...radiator05.jpg

http://www.the370z.com/members/stino...radiator07.jpg

http://www.the370z.com/members/stino...radiator08.jpg

370zrider 07-11-2013 12:38 AM

I think Mishimotos' won't fit with an intercooler + oilcooler

LafitteZ 07-11-2013 06:11 PM

The turbo intercoolers bolt to the location where the front crash bar usually is. There's tons of room between the intercooler and radiator. The sc guys don't have much room.

Mishimoto 07-12-2013 11:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370zrider (Post 2399809)
I think Mishimotos' won't fit with an intercooler + oilcooler

Quote:

Originally Posted by LafitteZ (Post 2400766)
The turbo intercoolers bolt to the location where the front crash bar usually is. There's tons of room between the intercooler and radiator. The sc guys don't have much room.

Hey guys,

We have tested our aluminum radiator with our direct fit oil cooler and fitment is perfect with no modification necessary. Our aluminum radiator is significantly thicker than the stock unit which may bring about questions regarding intercooler fitment. I spoke with our engineers and the Mishimoto radiator is expanded both frontward and backward in the car. This radiator adds 20mm to the front face of the radiator towards the front bumper. This means from the front of our radiator/AC condenser assembly to the end of the lower radiator support is around 50mm. This leaves around 4 inches of space between the A/C condenser and the back side of the bumper support beam.

If you are utilizing a front mount intercooler that is mounted in front of the crash beam then fitment should not be a problem at all. We have not tested fitment with an intercooler behind the crash beam so we are unable to confirm fitment. This really depends on the thickness of the cooler. If you would like to send me the specs of your intercooler I would be happy to compare this to our drawings and see if we can come to a conclusion. Being able to fit all Mishimoto cooling components and an intercooler really depends on the intercooler size and its mounting points. I would be happy to help with any specific questions, feel free to shoot me a PM. :tup:

Thanks!

Mr.Squeeze 08-01-2013 03:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370zrider (Post 2399809)
I think Mishimotos' won't fit with an intercooler + oilcooler



It will fit I know someone with one on a Turbo Z

I am switching out my CSF Radiator for the Mishimoto one in the next few weeks and will post results.

GaleForce 08-01-2013 06:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr.Squeeze (Post 2427940)
It will fit I know someone with one on a Turbo Z

I am switching out my CSF Radiator for the Mishimoto one in the next few weeks and will post results.

A rad might be on my winter project list... I'm looking to beef things up for some track days next summer. Looking forward to your results.

critical 08-04-2013 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSF Inc. (Post 2305203)
If you guys have any questions about our cooling system module, please let me know.

Remember: proper cooling is crucial to maintaining the logevity and stability of your engine, while allowing you to maximize power.

http://i1085.photobucket.com/albums/...92261479_n.jpg

I have a question. Can you tell me the specs on the power steering cooler? Looks like a direct bolt on replacement but a lot longer.

CSF Inc. 08-04-2013 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr.Squeeze (Post 2427940)
It will fit I know someone with one on a Turbo Z

I am switching out my CSF Radiator for the Mishimoto one in the next few weeks and will post results.

Remember guys, not all radiators are created equal.

Here is a comparison photograph taken this past week comparing CSF's industry leading "B-Tube" technology versus the "M" company's tubes.

It is apparent from the comaprison photo that our tubes:
1) Have a much better flow rate.
2) Our tubes have more surface area contact with the coolant allowing for better heat transfer efficiency (~15% more contact)
3) Because of the B-tube structure, we can use thinner aluminum but still have a stronger tube which has two advantages:
A) Ensures that non of our tubes are squished when the tubes are inserted into the headerplate during the manufacturing process. Sqished tubes significantly reduce the effectiveness of a radiator.
B) Allows for even better heat transfer efficiency because of the thinner aluminum.

"B-tube" technology is the world's best radiator tube only available in the performance aftermarket by CSF, a true radiator manufacture with over 65 years of experience and OE clients across the world.

http://i1085.photobucket.com/albums/...ompaarison.png

O&G 08-04-2013 06:15 PM

My Recent Mishimoto Experience
 
To Mishimoto from CSF? Never heard that one before. I just replaced my Mishimoto thermostat(left) with 4k miles on it for my stock unit(right) with 6k on it after hearing too many horror stories about their craftsmanship, leaky radiators and failed thermostats. As you can see the seal is already busted on the Mishimoto thermostat. I had a friend who had a Mishimoto thermostat fail on his Subaru which resulted in a ruined bottom end. From what I understand they make a decent oil cooler!
http://i251.photobucket.com/albums/g...ps073a168b.jpg

I do have the CSF radiator though, so I guess I can be labeled as biased.

Mr.Squeeze 08-04-2013 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CSF Inc. (Post 2432023)
Remember guys, not all radiators are created equal.

Here is a comparison photograph taken this past week comparing CSF's industry leading "B-Tube" technology versus the "M" company's tubes.

It is apparent from the comaprison photo that our tubes:
1) Have a much better flow rate.
2) Our tubes have more surface area contact with the coolant allowing for better heat transfer efficiency (~15% more contact)
3) Because of the B-tube structure, we can use thinner aluminum but still have a stronger tube which has two advantages:
A) Ensures that non of our tubes are squished when the tubes are inserted into the headerplate during the manufacturing process. Sqished tubes significantly reduce the effectiveness of a radiator.
B) Allows for even better heat transfer efficiency because of the thinner aluminum.

"B-tube" technology is the world's best radiator tube only available in the performance aftermarket by CSF, a true radiator manufacture with over 65 years of experience and OE clients across the world.

http://i1085.photobucket.com/albums/...ompaarison.png



Picture's look good but what matter is real world results. I have had the CSF radiator for some time and i can tell you right now it does not like to get pushed in heat . I have also seen both right next to each other ,and the Mishimoto is larger has 2 row for extra not one like the CSF. Now this does not make it better I will post the results like I have stated once I make the switch.

Make me a radiator that can handle at least 17-PSI of boost for one pull up to 150 mph hit 220+ coolant temp and not take forever to come down. I have gotten the CSF hot very easy and not even on my highest boost setting.

hyunsoo1803 08-11-2013 11:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mr.Squeeze (Post 2432219)
Picture's look good but what matter is real world results. I have had the CSF radiator for some time and i can tell you right now it does not like to get pushed in heat . I have also seen both right next to each other ,and the Mishimoto is larger has 2 row for extra not one like the CSF. Now this does not make it better I will post the results like I have stated once I make the switch.

Make me a radiator that can handle at least 17-PSI of boost for one pull up to 150 mph hit 220+ coolant temp and not take forever to come down. I have gotten the CSF hot very easy and not even on my highest boost setting.

I would like to know as well, please keep us informed :)

martin82 08-11-2013 11:25 AM

The ps cooler looks to me from a gtr

critical 08-11-2013 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by martin82 (Post 2441561)
The ps cooler looks to me from a gtr

thanks.



Question to CSF or Mishimoto. How does your 7AT cooling done through the radiator compare to the stock radiator and which is better?

Mandingo 08-11-2013 08:16 PM

G37 also has the longer oem ps cooler.

G37 power steering cooler

CSF Inc. 08-12-2013 11:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by critical (Post 2441740)
thanks.



Question to CSF or Mishimoto. How does your 7AT cooling done through the radiator compare to the stock radiator and which is better?

From what I understand, CSF is the only manufacture to produce a unit for the automatic transmission (CSF #7011). We use the same water-to-oil 7-plate transmission oil cooler as the original unit. This is the largest size we could fit into the unit.

martin82 08-12-2013 12:32 PM

nice, I didn't know the g37 had a bigger PS! good to know

1slow370 08-12-2013 09:09 PM

Doesn't the GTM radiator support the 7at also?

SS_Firehawk 08-12-2013 09:35 PM

Yes. But I would put that at a different price and performance bracket. You'll be spending $1400-$1700 for theirs because it requires a new fan shroud. It's overkill for most Z's.

Mishimoto 08-16-2013 11:13 AM

Our target market for this radiator was the manual transmission Z, with optimum performance in mind for these specific cars. Our radiator can be adapted to work with the automatic transmission, with the addition of our external transmission cooler.

advan37 08-18-2013 03:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mishimoto (Post 2448854)
Our target market for this radiator was the manual transmission Z, with optimum performance in mind for these specific cars. Our radiator can be adapted to work with the automatic transmission, with the addition of our external transmission cooler.

I will wait for automatic version .

DEpointfive0 09-04-2013 10:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrisSlicks (Post 2305315)
A little biased understandably. The GTM unit is also built to order so has a 6-8 week lead time. You need the radiator plus their custom shroud which bumps the price up significantly. The integrated oil heat exchanger is pretty sweet though and can be used either for cooling the A/T or on a manual to boost the engine oil cooling efficiency. The condenser is removable if you decide to go all track.

The PWR would be my first choice for a track only application with A/C delete, solid racing reputation. They are stocked by Nissan Motorsports but ordering through Nissan is trying.

Also do you homework regarding warranty replacements (for street vehicles).

... Heat exchanger is a little useless IMO, regular oil cooler would be much more efficient...
... CSF offers a 7AT version with a trans cooler too...
... CSF's condenser is removable too...

DEpointfive0 09-04-2013 11:04 PM

Yes, I'm biased now to CSF:
http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-g...r-service.html

clintfocus 09-04-2013 11:34 PM

proper shrouding for alot of the guys posting here would help huge. No one has even mentioned anything about that

Shadezz 09-05-2013 01:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DEpointfive0 (Post 2473626)

Made my choice easy...Thanks for the great review and story of customer service Depointfive!!:ugh2:

theDreamer 09-05-2013 07:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by clintfocus (Post 2473654)
proper shrouding for alot of the guys posting here would help huge. No one has even mentioned anything about that

Most are focused on a drop in solution, taking advantage of existing OEM parts.
Also, still waiting on results from another forum member if the GTM SPAL fan upgrade is plug-n-play with the CSF radiator. Instead of having to buy the fans, re-wire your fan controls, build new mounting solutions, etc.

Meulen 09-05-2013 07:42 AM

I don't understand. If you're NA and worried about water temp. Why not get a Thermostat?

theDreamer 09-05-2013 07:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meulen (Post 2473847)
I don't understand. If you're NA and worried about water temp. Why not get a Thermostat?

Because the ones for our car suck, one throws a CEL code, another is some cheap china made POS, and so far no one has made a decent upgrade.
Also, a radiator is a better solution, as while on the track it will help keep you much cooler versus the OEM radiator.

Chuck33079 09-05-2013 07:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Meulen (Post 2473847)
I don't understand. If you're NA and worried about water temp. Why not get a Thermostat?

Because the only lower temp aftermarket thermostat is Mishimoto, and they make cheap Chinese garbage that fail all of the time. If your thermostat fails closed, you're boned.

Meulen 09-05-2013 08:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by theDreamer (Post 2473849)
Because the ones for our car suck, one throws a CEL code, another is some cheap china made POS, and so far no one has made a decent upgrade.
Also, a radiator is a better solution, as while on the track it will help keep you much cooler versus the OEM radiator.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chuck33079 (Post 2473850)
Because the only lower temp aftermarket thermostat is Mishimoto, and they make cheap Chinese garbage that fail all of the time. If your thermostat fails closed, you're boned.

I wasn't aware they were that bad. I guess I found it hard to believe it was difficult to mess up such a simple part. I know some racing teams run them, however, I'm sure they rebuild those motors all the time anyway and longevity of a $65 part is probably the least of their problems.

thanks for the insight.

theDreamer 09-05-2013 08:03 AM

I would imagine many of the racing teams have custom radiators with completely different thermostats than ours to optimize their track performance and reliability.

Chuck33079 09-05-2013 08:06 AM

Anything Mishimoto has a high likelihood of giving you an issue. I used one of their radiators, and it fit terribly and the welds were horrendous. At least it held water. They'll come on here and say that their stuff is great and post a slick video, but you're rolling the dice. Besides outsourcing their production to [REDACTED], their quality control is godawful. Some people will get an acceptable part. Others (like one member here) have their thermostat fail in 6k miles.

ChrisSlicks 09-05-2013 09:35 AM

Both manufacturers products are made in China, but who you chose as the production partner means a lot I suppose.

I ended up installing the Mishimoto a month or so ago and track tested it, so far so good. The welds were clean, perhaps not the prettiest but then aluminum is difficult to weld. Water temperatures on track were lower and it held up under pressure which is all I cared about.

If I wanted the best I would go with PWR/Nismo (Australia) or GTM (outsourced to US producer), but these options are at least double the price and a lot harder to install, so maybe down the road if budget allows. Doran uses the PWR/Nismo unit.

CSF Inc. 09-05-2013 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChrisSlicks (Post 2474010)
Both manufacturers products are made in China, but who you chose as the production partner means a lot I suppose.

I ended up installing the Mishimoto a month or so ago and track tested it, so far so good. The welds were clean, perhaps not the prettiest but then aluminum is difficult to weld. Water temperatures on track were lower and it held up under pressure which is all I cared about.

If I wanted the best I would go with PWR/Nismo (Australia) or GTM (outsourced to US producer), but these options are at least double the price and a lot harder to install, so maybe down the road if budget allows. Doran uses the PWR/Nismo unit.

Our radiators are not manufactured in China, and we do not have an external production partner. We own and operate our own facotories. All of the R&D is done in-house, and we also have many OE clients around the world...

Just wanted to clear-up any misunderstandings people have about CSF. :tiphat:

clintfocus 09-05-2013 11:37 AM

Oh yeah, to contribute, i have a CSF rad, and the Nismo 34 row oil cooler with custom shrouding.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:39 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2