Hmmmm... somehow, I've JUST discovered this thread.
While I didn't read through every post, it seems that I may somewhat be in the minority as I am strictly a Bourbon guy. (I really don't care for 95% of the scotch I've tried, and I've tried a lot of 'em
)
I've got a pretty decent collection going...
Special Occasions/Sharing:
Weller 12 yr & 107
VanWinkle 10
Orphan Barrel Gifted Horse & Barterhouse
I W Harper 15 & 5 yr
Old Charter 13
Jeffersons Ocean 2nd voyage & Chef’s Collaboration
Russell’s Reserve 10 yr
Blanton’s
Bulleit 10
Elijah Craig 12 - Barrel proof
Colonel EH Taylor Small Batch
Noah’s Mill
Willet Pot Still
Blade & Bow
Old Forester 1870
Smooth Ambler Old Scout 10
Daily drinkers on constant rotation:
Eagle Rare 10
Elijah Craig 12
Buffalo Trace
Four Roses Small Batch
Knob Creek
Bulleit
Lately, I've really gotten back into the Buffalo Trace... very easy to drink neat and quite affordable... usually switching between that and the Eagle Rare 10... a damn bargain at $35 a bottle IMO.