Really not the same segment: Macan is a larger platform. X1 /// is closer to the GLA in terms of size and market.
Say what you want about appearances (soccer moms? really? Is it 1998?) but if you forced me to drive a SUV/SAV sized vehicle it would be a Macan then a Cayanne.
They handle amazingly well for their sizes. Go drive them and tell me you'd rather be in something else, including an X5 for example
- b