*Update*
Got offered from forgestar for them to make me an entire new set of wheels. They will be making a new set from scratch, shipping them to me, paying for my tires to be mounted and balanced, and then paying for shipping of the original wheels back to them. While I am still extremely disappointed in this whole ordeal, at least they are now going to replace the defective wheels.
Going to go with matte black this time, since I feel like the gloss black kinda makes the pearl white paint look faded. And no pinstripe because of the durability of the original.
Pictures of the current ones mounted if you haven't seen them
