Thanks for the kind words. I'm going to pay out of pocket since I know the body shop owner and insurance will just complicate things for the future.
Here's the jack I bought, but it wasn't the culprit. I jacked the car up too high on one side and the opposite tire slipped causing the jack to pop out. The garage floor is a treated cement that is a bit slippery. The jack is pretty sweet actually and well worth the money. Only complaint is the release is difficult to modulate for lowering the car slowly (and I mean the real release, not the 'pop out from under the car' release).
Low Profile Floor Jack - 2 Ton, Rapid Pump® Jack