Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Other Vehicles (http://www.the370z.com/other-vehicles/)
-   -   Should I get a GT-R? (http://www.the370z.com/other-vehicles/88950-should-i-get-gt-r.html)

MrGump 04-17-2014 11:28 PM

The fact that you are making car payments on the Z and are even worried about insurance costs answers your question...

You can always buy one in a year or two once (paying down your house payment is also not the best thing to do)....

If you buy it I'll keep an eye out for the inevitable "Selling GT-R cheap, something came up and can't keep her" thread.

Hotrodz 04-17-2014 11:31 PM

Boost the Z and pay down the house!!!!

synolimit 04-18-2014 12:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Waizzz (Post 2785394)
Payoff your house and keep the Z

You can get a GT-R later after you have paid down your debt. Last thing you need is for something to happen to your job and you have both a mortgage and 2 sports cars to payoff

Nothing in life is guaranteed

Well I think he'd pay cash for the gtr. So he could sell for a used price of like 20% off buying if he needed cash ASAP but I agree with you.

houkouonchi 04-18-2014 12:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ts-c63 (Post 2785340)
As much as I love the gtr and will more than likely be my next car, pay down the mortgage.

I am actually a mortgage banker, and the amount of money you will save on no longer having to pay the interest on your mortgage loan will make it worth it in the long run !!

Honestly the money in interest doesn't even bother me that much. I think the biggest reason to pay off my mortgage is so I could survive on really low cash-flow if I needed to or alternatively be able to save tons of money every month by not having a housepayment. Of course insurance and taxes still do cost a decent amount.

Even though I am semi-near L.A. I am far enough (right on the border of chino) that the houses are actually semi reasonable here. My house was only 260k (single-story 3 bd 2 bath, 1700 square feet) when I bought it 4 years ago and its actually now worth 340k.

I could have just paid for my Z in cash but why blow threw a huge chunk of my savings just to avoid a bit of interest? Honestly I am glad I did not because that money ended up being extremely usefull in allowing me to invest more in the company I work at which is part of the reason I am getting a big payout in the next few weeks (more than enough to buy a GT-R for cash if I wanted).

Maybe I just need to go test drive one and see if I like it but do dealers even let people test drive? even with >200k in the bank I would still be concerned about monthly effect on cashflow and insurance and stuff does matter. There is a good chance I could very well afford a GT-R even with a big hike in insurance already on my base salary without the huge checks I will be getting. I would like to still live within my means even if I get a decent sized payout.

Magic Bus 04-18-2014 03:46 AM

While it appears you have a nice little sum cash and decent income, I wouldn't do it. All you're doing by getting the GTR and keeping the Z is dramatically increasing your expenses in depreciating assets.

At age 28 I would invest the money in a diversified portfolio and build it up. When these investments build up more then use the dividends or income to pay the GTR bill. Leave or re-invest all the capital gains from these investments so your total portfolio balance increases. Be a little more patient, it's not like you have a crappy car now.

As for paying off your mortgage, it depends on what your interest rate is. Example, if your mortgage is 3%, and your investments average an annual rate of return of 8%, why use the investment money to pay off the mortgage? But you have to invest the additional money.

Let your money work for you instead of you working for your money. Short term sacrifice results in long term pleasure while short term pleasure results in long term suffering.

Sorry to be a party pooper but you seem to be in a great position to set yourself up for a nice financial future and get the GTR much easier several years down the road.

Good luck to you on whatever you decide.

Footloose301 04-18-2014 05:42 AM

Buy the GT-R and put the rest towards the mortgage.

You could potentially die today or tomorrow and you'll miss out on living life! If you're too conservative all your life you're going to miss out on all it has to offer!

Haboob 04-18-2014 05:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Footloose301 (Post 2785581)
Buy the GT-R and put the rest towards the mortgage.

You could potentially die today or tomorrow and you'll miss out on living life! If you're too conservative all your life you're going to miss out on all it has to offer!


That's true too.

I'm a prime example.


TapaTalk for iPhone.

marty31 04-18-2014 06:01 AM

What's your mortgage balance?

houkouonchi 04-18-2014 06:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by marty31 (Post 2785633)
What's your mortgage balance?

~230k

falconfixer 04-18-2014 07:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magic Bus (Post 2785530)
While it appears you have a nice little sum cash and decent income, I wouldn't do it. All you're doing by getting the GTR and keeping the Z is dramatically increasing your expenses in depreciating assets.

At age 28 I would invest the money in a diversified portfolio and build it up. When these investments build up more then use the dividends or income to pay the GTR bill. Leave or re-invest all the capital gains from these investments so your total portfolio balance increases. Be a little more patient, it's not like you have a crappy car now.

As for paying off your mortgage, it depends on what your interest rate is. Example, if your mortgage is 3%, and your investments average an annual rate of return of 8%, why use the investment money to pay off the mortgage? But you have to invest the additional money.

Let your money work for you instead of you working for your money. Short term sacrifice results in long term pleasure while short term pleasure results in long term suffering.

Sorry to be a party pooper but you seem to be in a great position to set yourself up for a nice financial future and get the GTR much easier several years down the road.

Good luck to you on whatever you decide.


This is the best advice so far in this thread.

edub370 04-18-2014 07:12 AM

$1100 a month car payment is absurd imo. pay off the z then go upgrade. driving a payed off Z is so much more satisfying :tup:

Elan 04-18-2014 07:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdavis89 (Post 2785193)
Since he asked, I will. I guess I'm in the minority here..imho that's not nearly enough money to be buying a car that expensive, but I tend to be conservative with my money. Affording the payments =/= Affording the car. Payoff debt, purchase with cash. $1,100/mth on a car? All I can think about are all the other things I could do with that each month. While I consider myself a car enthusiast, I do understand everyone has their own limits and what they value. I don't judge other people and what they do with their money, and the decision is yours, but that's just my two cents. :tup:

:iagree:

100k a year isn't THAT much for a car this expensive + insurance + mortgage + living expenses.

Don't buy it.

kielbasa16 04-18-2014 08:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hotrodz (Post 2785405)
Boost the Z and pay down the house!!!!

I like this advice. I agree with the fiscally conservative recommendations made thus far, but it sounds like you want to (and deserve to) splurge a little. Boosting the Z will make it even more fun to drive than it already is, plus you mentioned you prefer its looks to the GTR. Split the rest between some investments and the mortgage.

DjSquall 04-18-2014 08:55 AM

I say you should look into getting a used Gallardo. One can be easily found for under 100k. Maintenace & insurance is about the same as a GTR, but you get a Lambo ;)

2011 Nismo#91 04-18-2014 09:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by houkouonchi (Post 2785078)
Basically due to something with my work in the next few weeks I will probably be getting paid out upwards of $120-160k (exact amount is unknown).

Don't forget to factor in Uncle Sam will take a nice chunk of that income come next April 15th.

zguynate 04-18-2014 09:04 AM

I was going to say you would make way more than enough money to buy a GTR and easily pay your mortgage in a reasonable manner, but then I read you live in Cali lol. I wouldn't do it lol. If you made ~$150k here in Memphis you could live like a king.

370zseth 04-18-2014 09:33 AM

If you can swing it, do it.

houkouonchi 04-18-2014 09:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by falconfixer (Post 2785741)
This is the best advice so far in this thread.

I know financially it makes more sense to invest than pay off your mortgage but honestly there is risks involved in doing that where as if you pay your mortgage off its done, forever. Also the difference it can make in cash flow can be really nice so I think I would still like to try to pay it off but maybe invest in the interim until I have enough to do that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DjSquall (Post 2785934)
I say you should look into getting a used Gallardo. One can be easily found for under 100k. Maintenace & insurance is about the same as a GTR, but you get a Lambo ;)

When I was a kid a Lambo was my *dream* car but honestly as I have gotten older and heard all the horror stories of these things randomly combusting I honestly don't think I would want to actually own a lambo now.


Quote:

Originally Posted by 2011 Nismo#91 (Post 2785939)
Don't forget to factor in Uncle Sam will take a nice chunk of that income come next April 15th.

Oh yeah, I am very aware, Actually the number I gave was after factoring in a 40% loss due to taxes. Actual raw amount (which will come in as income) should be in the 190-250k range.

Chuck33079 04-18-2014 09:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magic Bus (Post 2785530)
While it appears you have a nice little sum cash and decent income, I wouldn't do it. All you're doing by getting the GTR and keeping the Z is dramatically increasing your expenses in depreciating assets.

At age 28 I would invest the money in a diversified portfolio and build it up. When these investments build up more then use the dividends or income to pay the GTR bill. Leave or re-invest all the capital gains from these investments so your total portfolio balance increases. Be a little more patient, it's not like you have a crappy car now.

As for paying off your mortgage, it depends on what your interest rate is. Example, if your mortgage is 3%, and your investments average an annual rate of return of 8%, why use the investment money to pay off the mortgage? But you have to invest the additional money.

Let your money work for you instead of you working for your money. Short term sacrifice results in long term pleasure while short term pleasure results in long term suffering.

Sorry to be a party pooper but you seem to be in a great position to set yourself up for a nice financial future and get the GTR much easier several years down the road.

Good luck to you on whatever you decide.

I came in here to type pretty much exactly this.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 2011 Nismo#91 (Post 2785939)
Don't forget to factor in Uncle Sam will take a nice chunk of that income come next April 15th.

And the state, right? He's in Cali. Between Fed and state tax, your 160k is probably 110k or less, right? $110k becomes $65k?

Seriously? Take a nice vacation so you can feel like you bought yourself something. Pay off the Z if you've still got a note. Make the house the only debt you have. Invest the rest. Revisit the GTR decision after a year of the new salary. Or wait for the redesigned GTR to crater the resale of the current ones and buy a 2013 or 2014 from someone who has to have the new one.

Amj2020 04-18-2014 09:47 AM

Id hate to point out the obvious but your posts make me think you are not financially ready to commit to this idea and want someone to talk you into it. I used to do the same thing when I wanted my first sports car, my first Rolex, my first boat all when I was your age. I wanted everyone to convince me it was the right decision to justify a predetermined bad choice. Instead I invested the money I had earned and saved, bought a house, started a family, all of which are very expensive and it turned out to be the right decision. The truth is even with that payout, the money would be much better and more wisely spent in 100 other ways than buying a GT-R. The GT-R will always be there, and so will a lot of other cars in the future that will make you want them instead of the GT-R. Is the GT-R fun, sure but want to know what is more fun, seeing 7 figures in your bank account! You are still very young, give it a few years and let that capital you are making work for you and earn more every month so that you can just say one day screw it, today im going to buy the 2017 GT-R and just flat out be able to afford it:)

Chuck33079 04-18-2014 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by houkouonchi (Post 2785985)
I know financially it makes more sense to invest than pay off your mortgage but honestly there is risks involved in doing that where as if you pay your mortgage off its done, forever. Also the difference it can make in cash flow can be really nice so I think I would still like to try to pay it off but maybe invest in the interim until I have enough to do that.

It's your only deduction, right? Don't hurry to get rid of it. Invest the money and let it grow. You're not really taking much risk to beat your mortgage interest rate as cheap as money is these days. And you can still cash out and send a check to the mortgage company if things get dicey.

ssmoked 04-18-2014 09:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by houkouonchi (Post 2785078)
Kind of been playing with the idea of getting a GT-R. Basically due to something with my work in the next few weeks I will probably be getting paid out upwards of $120-160k (exact amount is unknown). Its not enough to pay off my mortgage and I should also be getting a bump in my salary (currently making around 100k) but I have no clue how much of a bump. My payments on my 370z (which are almost done) are currently ~$500 and for quite a while I was paying $400/month for my internet and now I pay a lot less for my internet so it seems like the payments would be around $1100/month for a 60k loan on a used GTR with a modest down-payment. This amount seems actually pretty easily doable for me especially if I get a 10-15% bump in salary which it could possibly be even more (some weird circumstances at work I can't go into).

I really don't want to use any of that money I am getting and want to either invest or keep in a savings account to eventually pay off my house so even though I could buy a brand new GT-R in cash I don't think I would do that especially with the 2.5% financing right now. I know there are a few members on here who have both or had a GT-R and went back. I am curious how they liked it compared to the 370z? I am a pretty hard-core manual driver and this is actually the only car I would ever consider getting in an automatic (although with the way the transmission is I don't even know if it should be considered 'automatic).

I guess I wonder if those who are similar to me who have driven both what they think. I know the rear seats are super tiny but the very rare cases I need 3 seats its usually with my sister and she is super tiny so she could probably fit back there and the idea of having 4 seats is kind of nice.

Should I actually get a GT-R or am do you guys suggest I just pay off my Z and save my money and pay my house loan off faster?

My other concern is insurance. My insurance is currently $70/month on my 370Z (I am a male, 28 years old). Its not really a problem if the insurance goes up to $200 or so but if I get dinged with $600/month or something on insurance this may become a no-deal for me. Curious what the other Z drivers think. I think I would still keep my Z and occasionally drive that as well and it be my backup car.

I think the better question would be is your job stable enough to afford the payments on the car, house, and utility... what field are you in anyways?

FuTuRe is Z 04-18-2014 09:59 AM

Buy stock in Tesla they are going through the roof, trust me.

Additionally I will have to give the nod on waiting on your GT-R purchase, every vehicle purchase I've mad I've always had buyer's remorse. Please don't feel the same way I do. lol

Chuck33079 04-18-2014 10:05 AM

Just wait. They'll still be making GTRs in 3 years. How much could that lump sum be if you invested it for three years? At 10% each year, that's $212k. Four years is 230k. 10% is a reasonable rate of return to shoot for. At 10% annually it doubles in 7 years. At 28 your greatest asset is time to let things compound. Use your raise to pay more toward the mortgage if you have to pay it down, but if you're paying under 4% I wouldn't be in any hurry to get rid of the deduction.

kidkotic2001 04-18-2014 10:08 AM

My opinion would be to put that money towards your Mortgage, the faster you pay that off the better you will be. If not use half of that money to go toward your mortgage and invest the rest. Once you finish paying of the house you could get the GTR. I have been contemplating the same but if my bonus comes through like I think it is I am just going to pay my house first. I have about 90k still, I rather pay that off no further worries about home payments.

Chuck33079 04-18-2014 10:09 AM

Why is everyone in such a hurry to get rid of a low interest rate tax deductible mortgage? If you're paying less than 5% on the note, invest it and make money on the difference. You can always sell the investments and pay off the note if things get tight.

my2004Z 04-18-2014 10:38 AM

More often than not when someone makes more money or pays something off they go and get themselves into more debt. Try saving your money for a few years all while working to lower your recurring fixed costs. Cash flow is king especially since it enables geometric growth of investments. Before you know it you'll be able to put 75% down on the next generation version of the GT-R and can pay the rest off quickly.
:tiphat:

ElVee 04-18-2014 10:44 AM

0. I didn't read the whole thread. Sorry!

1. Wait until you actually HAVE the money and can afford it if, say, you lose your job next month or whatever deal is going down ends up tanking. (To me, a raise is never a raise until I have it signed and in hand.)

2. If the scenario includes any question about a mortgage, then you deal with the mortgage first. Your house is good debt, and an appreciative asset. Your car, even a GTR, is not good debt and likely will depreciate some.

Deal with the mortgage that you have currently, then look at bad debt.

But financially, it's really only business between you and your advisor/loan agent, so if you can afford it, feel free. I certainly won't judge any decision if you can afford it.

Fuzzzy 04-18-2014 11:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by falconfixer (Post 2785741)
This is the best advice so far in this thread.

+1

From a not-so-recently retired person who recently took out the first auto loan of his life (to buy a new 370) simply because that was the best financial option at this time.

Codename067 04-18-2014 02:36 PM

GTRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!! My next car, I am 90% sure! The other 10% is an E92 M3. Haha.

Quote:

Originally Posted by tjlazer (Post 2785123)
The 370Z is funner to drive and handles better so if you can, keep the Z. (Z is upgraded with full bolt ons, full exhaust, sways and Swift springs though, GT-R is stock. I'm sure with sways and coils the GT-R would handle a lot better...)

Besides the exhaust...those ups gave your Z an edge over GTRs stock handling???

Serious question! I'm curious to know!

tjlazer 04-18-2014 04:42 PM

^ well all I know is my Z handles amazing with the Hotchkis sways and Swift Spec R's. Corners like it's on rails, and feels "light" compared to the GT-R. But I'm sure if I got springs/coils and sways it would feel and handle much better! I remember how the 370Z felt stock!

Waiz 04-18-2014 04:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Magic Bus (Post 2785530)
While it appears you have a nice little sum cash and decent income, I wouldn't do it. All you're doing by getting the GTR and keeping the Z is dramatically increasing your expenses in depreciating assets.

At age 28 I would invest the money in a diversified portfolio and build it up. When these investments build up more then use the dividends or income to pay the GTR bill. Leave or re-invest all the capital gains from these investments so your total portfolio balance increases. Be a little more patient, it's not like you have a crappy car now.

As for paying off your mortgage, it depends on what your interest rate is. Example, if your mortgage is 3%, and your investments average an annual rate of return of 8%, why use the investment money to pay off the mortgage? But you have to invest the additional money.

Let your money work for you instead of you working for your money. Short term sacrifice results in long term pleasure while short term pleasure results in long term suffering.

Sorry to be a party pooper but you seem to be in a great position to set yourself up for a nice financial future and get the GTR much easier several years down the road.

Good luck to you on whatever you decide.

This is what I would normally suggest to someone in person but on the forum this advice gets thrown into a black hole.

Your advice is what I have been doing for myself since 2006 and made an average return of at least 15%-20% every year by investing in the market.

OP, for a mortgage of $230k just keep paying down your mortgage and save/invest your money instead of looking to drop a big chunk into another car or paying off a mortgage given that it is already a fixed cost.

I could easily afford a GT-R or similar priced car right now but I choose to invest that money instead because I have been through the ups and downs of the economy for the last 8 years and I know better than to throw my money at a rapidly depreciating asset.

jaedub 04-18-2014 04:54 PM

Worry about your house first. Car second. Then your wife

tjlazer 04-18-2014 04:59 PM

Yep and when you are 55 you can buy your R35! ;)

houkouonchi 04-18-2014 05:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ssmoked (Post 2786005)
I think the better question would be is your job stable enough to afford the payments on the car, house, and utility... what field are you in anyways?

I actually work in an extremely desirable field. I am a senior-level Linux Systems Administrator and also do programming (devops). I have actually had recruiters from facebok go find my work email address after I didn't respond to them on linkedin. I honestly don't think I would ever really have trouble finding another job if I needed to. I really like where I work now because I get 25 days a year of vacation as well as 10 sick-days so 35 days a year of paid time off (280 hours per year). Also I telecommute half of the time so I usually don't even have to go into the office.

Thanks for all the input guys. I think what I really wanted to know is if the GTR is really worth it for people who have both a 370Z and a GTR or who have driven both. Even with a huge chunk of money I did not want to use that to actually buy a GT-R and instead wanted to get a loan and it to be at the level where I could pay it without eating into my savings just with my base salary which probably will be the case.

I guess I will just have to find an opportunity to actually go drive one and see how I like it. I think I am probably leaning a bit more towards just paying off the Z and helping my current cash-flow so I can save more and pay off the house quicker though.

Magic Bus 04-18-2014 06:12 PM

Houkouonchi, sounds like you're a pretty sharp guy and think of things before you react, so I'll just give you some food for thought.

Regarding paying off your mortgage early, there are valid reasons for doing this, especially if your interest rates are on the high side. If not, consider investing the difference in a moderate portfolio (maybe an equal mix of bond/stocks, mutual funds are ok). But once again, you must invest the difference, not spend it.

The question we need to ask ourselves is who's better off? Someone who has paid off his mortgage but has no cash or someone who has a $100,000 mortgage but $150,000 in cash? I know what my answer is.

Once again, good luck to you. :tiphat:

Malm 04-18-2014 06:42 PM

man, I am just trying to save for 2k wheels..

life is good man, do what your gut says.

onzedge 04-18-2014 07:47 PM

You thought you had fun driving your Z like an azz, as witnessed in your infamous videos depicting you speeding through downtown LA in traffic (with complete disregard for others' safety)? You can be the king in the GT-R.

ssmoked 04-18-2014 09:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by houkouonchi (Post 2786505)
I actually work in an extremely desirable field. I am a senior-level Linux Systems Administrator and also do programming (devops). I have actually had recruiters from facebok go find my work email address after I didn't respond to them on linkedin. I honestly don't think I would ever really have trouble finding another job if I needed to. I really like where I work now because I get 25 days a year of vacation as well as 10 sick-days so 35 days a year of paid time off (280 hours per year). Also I telecommute half of the time so I usually don't even have to go into the office.

Thanks for all the input guys. I think what I really wanted to know is if the GTR is really worth it for people who have both a 370Z and a GTR or who have driven both. Even with a huge chunk of money I did not want to use that to actually buy a GT-R and instead wanted to get a loan and it to be at the level where I could pay it without eating into my savings just with my base salary which probably will be the case.

I guess I will just have to find an opportunity to actually go drive one and see how I like it. I think I am probably leaning a bit more towards just paying off the Z and helping my current cash-flow so I can save more and pay off the house quicker though.

In that case, especially with a stable field, go for it and get the GTR and have fun! You only live once! What's the point of having disposable income and not use it to bring joy? Do it before the wife and kids, it would be a few decades until another opportunity arise!! At the end of the day, it's only a number in the bank. Can't take it with you when a person dies, example steve jobs

FairladyZ10PG 04-18-2014 11:04 PM

Enjoy life to the fullest! If that means purchasing gozirra, go for it! Yolo~ :) But only do it responsibly.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:31 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2