Originally Posted by molamann (Post 279071)

So this thread's got me thinking, is the 370Z underpowered for its purpose or is the 335i just damn fast for a sedan/coupe touring car? I mean it seems like the 335i isn't lagging too much behind the 370Z in handling either, so what's the point of getting the 370Z other than wanting a "pure" sports car by sacrificing seats, noise, etc?

Originally Posted by MightyBobo (Post 279378)

Well, some would argue the Z keeps getting fatter, and hence the increased power is less effective. Others would argue that the 335i is a twin-turbo 6-cylinder, and by that very virtue would more than likely be a quick car with lots of potential.

Either way, I wouldn't say the Z is underpowered too much at all. Its all in what the car was designed for in the first place - its obvious what the Z is for, but the 335i is a bit more vague. In reality, it was made for men who want a little more umph from the car they daily drive to work and to the golf course. But can it take corners the same as the 370Z? Hardly. But you post a very good question - what IS the point in buying the Z over the 335i? To many, image. A 2-seater sports car to many is viewed as a sign of youth, maybe even a bit rebellious nature in this time of practicality.

Originally Posted by molamann (Post 279071)

So this thread's got me thinking, is the 370Z underpowered for its purpose or is the 335i just damn fast for a sedan/coupe touring car? I mean it seems like the 335i isn't lagging too much behind the 370Z in handling either, so what's the point of getting the 370Z other than wanting a "pure" sports car by sacrificing seats, noise, etc?

Originally Posted by m4a1mustang (Post 279415)

Anything less than an LS2/LS7 is underpowered, IMO.

Originally Posted by MightyBobo (Post 279378)

Well, some would argue the Z keeps getting fatter, and hence the increased power is less effective. Others would argue that the 335i is a twin-turbo 6-cylinder, and by that very virtue would more than likely be a quick car with lots of potential.

Either way, I wouldn't say the Z is underpowered too much at all. Its all in what the car was designed for in the first place - its obvious what the Z is for, but the 335i is a bit more vague. In reality, it was made for men who want a little more umph from the car they daily drive to work and to the golf course. But can it take corners the same as the 370Z? Hardly. But you post a very good question - what IS the point in buying the Z over the 335i? To many, image. A 2-seater sports car to many is viewed as a sign of youth, maybe even a bit rebellious nature in this time of practicality.

Originally Posted by zero (Post 279432)

I got the Z because my golf bag fits perfectly in the trunk. :tup:

Originally Posted by Red370 (Post 278212)

No sir. What I will do is say that 332hp, for a NA V6, regardless of price, is DAMN good. You have your opinion, I have mine. You choose to compare the VQ to an engine that costs 4 times as much, and in doing a comparo, you compare the average engine output for its size with other cars IN ITS CLASS, by which the GT3 is not. Now back to the point at hand, also comparatively speaking, your comparing a Flat 6 against a V6, two completely different configurations, one built for efficiency and power equally, and one strictly for all out speed applications. Case in point the VQ, excellent power while having decent fuel economy. The GT3 is a race bred car, and thats it. So to say that 332bhp for a V6 is bad, i'd say you are terribly misguided sir.

Originally Posted by F430Spider (Post 223451)

Funny coming from a miata driver. :eek:

Originally Posted by vash_241987 (Post 279167)

I think its all of personal matter. Since both are about the same for power and performance here are what I'm listing as areas that can help choose what is best for your needs and wants. (strictly IMO)

Seating:
370z-if you are single and don't have alot of friends, this is your car. Why have the extra weight of two usless seats in the back? It'll also make you feel like your a man..... :bowrofl:.....not really, but it does give you the sports car feel.
335i-if you have friends, and are always out and about handing at clubs or bars, the two extras seats are helpful. (more pockets of gas money ;)) It's also helpful for any 'emergency' situations when you and group of friends or family are going somewhere and space is scarce in other friends cars.

Brand name:
Sometime in your past life you've been a brand whore....but sometimes you got to realize that your fav. company is just not giving the goods *cough* toyota *cough*. So if you are looking for the car you want you'll have to do a comparsion with all the different brands, and see if they offer what you want.

Pricing:
No brainer, if its new vs. new your probably going to go for the one that gives you more bang for the buck. I guess the same can go you you can find the more expensive one used for about the same price.

Repaires:
Can you afford the upkeep of the car? More stuff you can DIY like oil change, but when it comes to the routine check ups, the euro cars can be as much as what your paying monthly.

Interior Quality:
Want luxury and lots of options or doable interior that just gives you the basic stuff.

I think you can get my drift....its all personal tastes. I left out alot of other stuff like realiability, fiancing, insurance, but im too lazy. As for me, I think the biggest difference would be the routine maintenance, I would opt for the cheaper one, and also exclusivity....lots of people have 335i around here vs. the two 370z i've seen here. Ok thats my rant....I'm going to eats some PB M&M and sip on some hot cocoa with a shot of espresso :excited:

Originally Posted by ianthegreat (Post 222470)

Oh you feel it... every line, crack, or peice of gum stuck on the road.

Originally Posted by BimmerPhile (Post 1850754)

How did that work out?



There's so much blatant fanboyism here it is crazy.


I laugh at how everybody's defense is that BMWs are ugly. Are you serious?

Originally Posted by BimmerPhile (Post 1850754)

How did that work out?



There's so much blatant fanboyism here it is crazy.


I laugh at how everybody's defense is that BMWs are ugly. Are you serious?