Nissan 370Z Forum - What is a STOCK 370Z with MT actually putting down?

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)

- Nissan 370Z General Discussions (http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-general-discussions/)

- - What is a STOCK 370Z with MT actually putting down? (http://www.the370z.com/nissan-370z-general-discussions/18716-what-stock-370z-mt-actually-putting-down.html)

you guys are funny... do you even know what torque is? Torque is force applied over a radius... the ONLY thing torque affects is how quickly you accept change... think inertia of motion. You are sitting at rest and you need to move - the tq you produce tells you how much easier it will be for your system to resist rest (please go brush up on your physics)...

Klubb is absolutely right - when he says that the torque helps out more down low - let me try and explain why...

When your car is traveling 0 or 20 mph (low speeds) your TQ speaks volumes of how quickly you can accelerate... once you get up to 100+ (in most cars) you are only going to be increasing your speed by a few mph per instance (as compared to down low where tq plays a much more significant role)... so your car does not have to overcome rest as much - since its only going from lets say 100-105 compared to like 20-40 (takes about the same time)... up high it all comes down to how much power your car makes.

Torque = r x F = |F|*|r|*sin(theta) where the force being applied is your instantaneous forward force being generated by your engine (it needs to get converted to angular momentum etc etc etc)

"Torque is the static measurement of how much work an engine does, while power is a measure of how fast the work is being done. Since horsepower is calculated from torque, what we are all seeking is the greatest-possible torque value over the broadest-possible rpm range. Horsepower will follow suit, and it will fall in the engine speed range dictated by the many factors that affect the torque curve."

So in essence - these are things that are inter-related HEAVILY - i mean one is simply directly proportional to another (per rpm). Its like asking whats more important? steering wheels? or brakes? LOL... What you CAN infer from a HP / TQ curve is simply how efficiently that engine is making power - take the numbers together - they mean a LOT more...

Quote:

Originally Posted by shabarivas (Post 529228)

I don't know where we ever didn't acknowledge that...and as an engineering student...I understand the principle of torque quite well. We were just arguing over what is most important in a race, to have more torque or horsepower. I'm pretty sure we agreed that they are both important, and yes, horsepower is more important in higher speeds because it measures how much force it can provide in overcoming air resistance which is basically the limiting factor in car speed.

Quote:

Originally Posted by klubbheads (Post 529082)

That example that you are talking about is true on the initial acceleration of the car. TQ will allow you to accelerate faster in short period of time (redline is lower). HP will keep you accelerating longer with less force. A car that makes its peak tq from 2000-5500 RPM such as my old 335, had great acceleration at any given RPM but peak power came around 6000rpm even though it redlined at 7k. It was great on low speed races but it was not once you stay get to speeds (higher rev range). The perfect example is the AMG cars VS M5. AMG cars are faster at lower speeds but the M5 smokes most of them anything over 120mph. Why? Because it accelerates for longer period of time with its higher redline. Same example can be used with s2k vs other cars that had twice the tq such as the z33 also ferraris vs lambos. Every manufacturer has its own way of building an engine, its just a matter preference what you are into. Me higher redline and higher peak hp > than bunch of tq and lower rpm peak power.

Both are very important and depend on each other. The thing that will not change is that higher RPM peak power = less tq and vice versa. Again TQ wins races is not an accurate statement.

Also hold on...how are you arguing this? I just said two cars, one of which making more torque, assuming everything else equal, the one with more torque will win...lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by smashwebs (Post 529251)

Also hold on...how are you arguing this? I just said two cars, one of which making more torque, assuming everything else equal, the one with more torque will win...lol

To answer your question about two identical engines: the one with higher peak HP will win the race. consistent tq throughout the RPM means lower peak HP out put so technically two engines can not be identical except one having more tq.