Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Forced Induction (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/)
-   -   GMT stage 1 or 2 (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/47429-gmt-stage-1-2-a.html)

Z eliminator 01-04-2012 07:22 PM

So if ran a stage ! on my car and shifted at 6500 rpm my feeling is that it would beat the stage 2 in the 1/4 mile.
Look at the diference in torque and rwhp. it huge up to 6500 rpm.
we are just going to have to wait to see what my stage 2 will do in the 1/4 mile with the 4.08 gears.
What would it make with a meth kit (stage 1) ? i guess would be 450 rwhp
Z

travisjb 01-04-2012 07:38 PM

^ from 5k to 6.5k rpm, it looks like an avg ~15 whp difference favoring the st1 over st2 for this particular configuration on these cars at the times they were run. of course the st2 will be tunable to higher #s... and the st2 is on average ~15 whp higher than the st1 from 6.5k to 7.5k... my guess is it would be roughly a wash with these two cars as they are set up, assuming they both shift at redline

in addition, i like the very linear acceleration that is likely to result from the st2, all the way to redline it should pull like a bmw

only downside for me with the st2 is power/weight classing based upon peak power! I think I may put a rev limit in of 7k in order to meet my target

Zat_Zuma 01-05-2012 03:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike@GTM (Post 1474702)
To say that the Stage 1 Kit is maxed out isn’t exactly true.

*EDITED*

There is a brand new Nismo that we just got here in the shop that is getting our Stage 1 Supercharger kit with the Stage 2 compressor housing and intake. We’ll just call it Stage 1.5 for now. The results will show that the C38-81 supercharger unit is NOT maxed out in terms of horsepower.

*EDITED*

Ultimately, however, the Stage 1 has a lot of area under the curve...even if it doesn't make as much power as the Stage 2.

Yes that's what I want to accomplish and strive for with the meth injection ....... a 1.5 meth/SC ..... after I get my *ahem* issue resolved with my Z. The upgrade plan is under way with new CJM parts to be on order shortly.

Please post the results achieved with the Nismo 1.5.

Looking forward to what results can happen with a free breathing stage 1 and meth injection, drag radials and DSS axles. :tup:

It's going to be a interesting spring time

Kirkster 01-05-2012 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by weiboy718 (Post 1474830)
^ how the hell do you make 9-10psi on the stage 1 kit? The most I made was 8.4 and sometimes it won't even get to 8psi.

Don't have a good answer for you on that... All the beasts are a bit different...

In June I was running 8.2~8.7psi. Now I am hitting 9.6~10.3psi in the cold

My gauge records peak boost and lets me look at it at a later time so I usually check that to ensure that I don't have a boost leak before I get shut down the car.

I run her pretty hard all the time and am on the 91 octane map all the time, as I wanted a bit more safety as I always run 93 octane gas.

12K with the supercharger and she does not burn a drop of oil in 3500 miles :hello:

Nixlimited 01-05-2012 04:08 PM

Oh man, if there really was a stage 1.5, that would make my choice way more interesting...

Looking at those dynos though, Mike, would you say that the current stage 1 compressor side is maxed out? It really falls flat after 6500 RPMs.

Man, this reminds me a lot of choosing a turbo for my STi ... big versus little.

sojirovskensi 01-05-2012 05:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nixlimited (Post 1477669)
Oh man, if there really was a stage 1.5, that would make my choice way more interesting...

Looking at those dynos though, Mike, would you say that the current stage 1 compressor side is maxed out? It really falls flat after 6500 RPMs.

Man, this reminds me a lot of choosing a turbo for my STi ... big versus little.

there is such a thing for s/c 1.5, i talked with Mike about it

prescott3656 01-05-2012 09:13 PM

I'd like to see the difference on the stage 1 after the stage 2 compressor housing upgrade...

wind.zero 01-06-2012 10:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pokeyl (Post 1471296)
Again, has anyone put 15K miles on a SC car last year? Did you have any problems? Stage 1 or 2?

If I want go big or say home, I'll go port nitrous til the motor pops!!!! Way more BANG for the buck!!!!

I put 6k miles on a Stage 1 kit in about 5 months. Here is my review if you are interested.

This is just my personal opinion and it applies just to the GTM SC Kit Stage 1. This is just my 2 cents and is a long read. There is more to your decision of Stage 1 or 2. There is a lot involved with going FI on the 370z. You might already know this information but it might be helpful for others making the same decision.

I have been on the GTM Stage 1 kit for 5 months and have put 6k on it since the install. The only problems I have encountered with the kit were 2 oil leaks and a slight idle problem. Other than that, knock on wood, I have been extremely happy with GTM and the SC impresses me every time I drive the car.

Decisions, decisions ….
Several people have asked me about the SC decision and this is what I tell them. You have to make some important decisions about the direction of the performance of your 370 up front. If you start out with the standard bolt-ons and then go FI, you are going to waste a lot of cash. So up front, either decide to stay NA or go FI. I also like the fact that the Stage 1 is low impact on the car. You have to look to even know it is installed. It looks like aftermarket air intakes. 75% of the people who look in my engine bay cannot find the SC. No kidding ….

The next decision is you have to make a personal commitment to the additional cost of the supplemental parts and potential labor to support the GTM SC kit. This is no negative on GTM, but they sell a turn-key FI kit. That kit includes all of the FI parts, but does include the supplemental accessories I think are necessary to help ensure longevity of the motor. Again, this is just my opinion.

Supplemental Parts
The fact of the matter is the 370z runs on the hot side for coolant and oil temperatures. You as the customer need to decide what you want to install to keep your fluids at an acceptable level. I live in Texas and we had record heat last summer; thus, my car suffered with some high oil temps.

GTM does offer a great selection of parts to supplement the kit. I am specifically talking about upgraded cooling fans, shrouds, radiator, and a myriad of oil cooling solutions. I think it would be a good business decision to add options to the SC kit that include some of these cooling solutions at a reduced price rather than adding them after the fact. I know some of these parts are new and just released so maybe that is in the works.

So I decided up front I was going with the GTM SC kit. The Stage 2 had just been released but I went with the Stage 1 for several reasons.
  • The Stage 1 kit was available and the Stage 2 was a 6-8 week wait, and I am not known for patience. GTM has probably caught up on production now anyway.
  • Stage 1 is less cash outlay than Stage 2
  • The install labor at my shop was less for Stage 1 versus Stage 2
  • I had a better shot with OEM clutch longevity with Stage 1 (meaning less cost out of pocket up front or soon). I am well aware at some point, the CSC and clutch will succumb to my lead foot.
  • I thought that ~400WHP would be enough for street use because I do not track my car. Sure the Stage 2 would have been more power, but I went with the Stage 1 anyway. Still happy with that decision today in fact.
I do not want to debate any of these, but those were my reasons for going Stage 1.

Maintenance
The next commitment is a higher standard for regular or routine maintenance. If you are used to driving your car around and doing little to no maintenance, any FI is probably not for you.

What do I mean by higher standard of maintenance?
  • I check my oil level at least every other day and my car is a DD. I discovered 2 oil leaks on a pad that I park over to indicate fluid leaks. The first leak was coming from a loose oil cooler line and the other was a seal on the sandwich plate. Thus, if you are used to not checking things like this, perhaps FI is not for you.
  • A lot of people have the ideology that I have a new car with new seals, so nothing is going to leak for 50-60k miles. That is not true. Adding FI to your car requires a lot of parts that deliver fluids so things may have to be adjusted or seals have to be replaced. You have to be prepared to deal with things like this. No it is not a high maintenance thing to some, but you do have to deal with it one way or the other.
  • I change my oil and filter every 3k miles. I have an extra capacity oil pan so that means 7 quarts and a filter.
  • I check my Rotrex fluid level once a week, and I am prepared perform the recommended maintenance interval for the SC. This is a $300 kit from GTM that includes the Rotrex traction fluid, SC oil filter, SC belt, and a spray to clean the by-pass valve. They say a 50k interval but I will probably do this at about 30k.
  • I am paranoid about the plastic CSC going, so I check my clutch fluid at least 1x a week. I keep a fund available just to replace the CSC and clutch. I know at some point it will go simply because I am putting down more HP and torque. I do not have a magic wand, but I know the stock clutch will fail me at some point.
  • The Stage 1 air filters are located where the windshield washer reservoir was installed. So to service the air filters, you have to raise the car, remove the wheel, and remove the fender lining to access the two filters. To some this is easy, but to others used to changing panel filters in the engine bay, it is more involved. I think Sam said to service them every other oil change, so I am due to clean and re-oil my filters.

The whole point I am trying to make is when a NA car is stock, you can neglect checking a lot of things and the car still runs relatively well for a long time. With bolt-ons, other than from an emissions perspective, there is not a whole lot of maintenance required on the parts. With any FI install, there is a lot more going on, so you as the responsible owner must decide if you are in or out or what has to be maintained to keep the grin in your face when you mash the accelerator.

Hope this helps with your decision. GTM is a great vendor and source of information. Sam and Mike have been most helpful with me during the entire process including service after the sale which is very important to me.

I am right at 380WHP on a conservative tune from SAM on a dyno pull in 115 degree heat. I hope to have a full tune done in the late winter or spring and come closer to the 400WHP mark.

m4a1mustang 01-06-2012 10:08 AM

Great post wind.zero :tup:

Streetlife 01-06-2012 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by m4a1mustang (Post 1478668)
Great post wind.zero :tup:


I agree, his post was as informative as it can get for those thinking about FI.:tiphat:

weiboy718 01-06-2012 01:04 PM

Agree! Someone should sticky that post before it gets buried.

sojirovskensi 01-06-2012 06:02 PM

I was lucky that I had a chance to get a ride with wind.zero's car about 2-3 weeks ago.
Once the car launched, first 1 second it goes like my z (310whp), but I could feel a great torque kicking in around 3.5~4k rpm. He did a couple of 40mph starting, and this time it was a totally different feeling from the beginning since he could launch from above 3500 rpm.
Throughout the first and second gear, I could hear somewhat unpleasant sound of S/C, but it was not that bad. I am sure that I will get used to it just like road noise from the stock 370z. Breathing sounds are awesome. I personally like it more than bov.

It seems very fun to drive as well as fun to ride in the passenger seat.
We were literally laughing all the time during the drive.
For those who may think S/C don't have enough torque to put you deep in the seat, but it was not true. It was as fun as a turbocharged car to me (like stock Evo/sti)

Overall, it was a great experience for me to decide to go with S/C stage 1 later on. I was debating between S/C and TT both stage 1, and I was very concerned of torque rather than horsepower. For me, who don't really go to track, S/C stage 1 will give me enough power to put a smile on my face.

It is very true that you will get used to the power within 2-3 weeks anyway.
For instance, I have a friend who used to have R35 HKS 600 kit with 650 awhp, and recently he is done with HKS 800 with 4.2L engine upgrade which now makes 960 awhp.
After 10 days of driving, he is thirsty of more power.

The point here is that, you will feel like wanting more power anyway.
Think of what you need your car for, but personally, s/c stage 1 sounds enough for me as a DD.

Mkai0 01-06-2012 08:37 PM

wind.zero,

excellent post, probably the best review I've seen so far for this kit. I'll be looking forward to next review when the SC oil gets changed out!

roplusbee 01-07-2012 09:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Streetlife (Post 1478707)
I agree, his post was as informative as it can get for those thinking about FI.:tiphat:

:iagree:

GUTCH 01-13-2012 03:16 AM

Here's a question some of you might hate but it means the world to me:

0-62mph & 62-95mph

Stage I or Stage II?

Oh and if the result it that one kit is better for one of the above speed ranges than the other, I'm going to bang my head against a wall until it bleeds.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:55 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2