Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Forced Induction (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/)
-   -   Engine/Transmission/etc reliability + FI (http://www.the370z.com/forced-induction/45415-engine-transmission-etc-reliability-fi.html)

awkwardturtle 11-14-2011 09:52 PM

Engine/Transmission/etc reliability + FI
 
Perhaps I'm blind, and that's very possible, but I couldn't find much on here about this topic.

Right now I drive a turbocharged 2007 Civic SI, and it's a rolling timebomb. The motors in those cars can handle boost very well, but my transmission is eventually going to shear a gear at these power levels of ~440 whp. They tend to last about 2 years for the lucky ones, 4 months for the reckless ones.

In my next car, I plan on making big power (500+ whp), and I want to make sure I buy a car that can actually sustain these power levels without complete overhauls.

So, I'm wondering what the limits of this car is in terms of FI. I see a lot of 500+ whp builds - can the engine, transmission, axles, etc sustain this kind of force for a decent amount of time? On my car, our only options really are to spend 4k+ on PPG/Albin gears. I can't even imagine what gears for this car would cost, and I don't really want to find out!

Thanks

Dembflyr 11-15-2011 08:40 AM

I read somewhere that the 6 speed transmission is capable of handling upwards of 700 ft lbs of torque. The weak spot in the 6sp is most certainly the syncros. The second weak spot is the concentric slave cylinder. The CSC housing is made of plastic from the factory. This causes issues when a stronger clamping clutch is used.
I had my trans replaced for syncro issues before I went TT. I still have the stock clutch and I am putting down 474 hp. So far no issues after 5000+ boosted miles.

I have no experience with the automatic. I have read about a couple of 7AT failures on the forum and the reason seems to be that the higher gears can't handle the added torque. But I will leave further explanation to those with more experience.

The durability of the engine has been dissucssed here many times. Here is the short story.
These engines are strong. The durability is all in the tune (to a point)
Many feel that the safe point is right around 500 WHP on a stock block.

In my opinion, go with a 6MT if you don't want to worry about the trans and just build the bottom end of the engine. That would probably allow 600 WHP all day long without worry.

John@Z1 11-15-2011 08:55 AM

Get a 6spd 370Z and no worries. We have tuned a number of 500+hp street abused 370Z's that have only had clutch failure(on a full face clutch). We even tuned a 7AT that is still rolling on the stock tranny making high 4++ at the wheels.

370Z=Happiness!

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 09:51 AM

It would be a 6spd without a doubt, no automatics here. Interesting to know the car can make 500 whp no problems. hrmmm...

fuct 11-15-2011 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408020)
It would be a 6spd without a doubt, no automatics here. Interesting to know the car can make 500 whp no problems. hrmmm...

it is!!! just be prepared to spend more than double what boosting the Si cost.

Mike@GTM 11-15-2011 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fuct (Post 1408216)
it is!!! just be prepared to spend more than double what boosting the Si cost.

More than double? Um, no. To get the numbers the OP is talking about, the universal e-bay kits aren't going to cut it. lol

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 11:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike@GTM (Post 1408242)
More than double? Um, no. To get the numbers the OP is talking about, the universal e-bay kits aren't going to cut it. lol

You can see about 500 whp on a k20 for about $5k

Mike@GTM 11-15-2011 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Red__Zed (Post 1408258)
You can see about 500 whp on a k20 for about $5k

hmmm...maybe I was looking at the wrong kits. do you have a link?

corbin09 11-15-2011 01:50 PM

Mike- How much would it cost to replace the syncros on a 6mt with something stronger?

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 01:56 PM

I spent nearly 10 grand boosting my SI. I know all about purchasing quality parts :) In fact, the kit itself for my car cost more than what I'm seeing for TT/SC kits for this car, but I'm sure there are other parts besides the kits needed whereas my kit was 100% inclusive of everything needed. If a TT or SC for this car costs 10-12k, I would be ok with that. Much more than that and I would question my sanity. For my specific car, you would never see 500 whp for 5k unless you bought really crappy parts, or bought them used.

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 02:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike@GTM (Post 1408349)
hmmm...maybe I was looking at the wrong kits. do you have a link?

Offhand, no. I can dig for some once I'm not browsing from a phone.
Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408488)
I spent nearly 10 grand boosting my SI. I know all about purchasing quality parts :) In fact, the kit itself for my car cost more than what I'm seeing for TT/SC kits for this car, but I'm sure there are other parts besides the kits needed whereas my kit was 100% inclusive of everything needed. If a TT or SC for this car costs 10-12k, I would be ok with that. Much more than that and I would question my sanity. For my specific car, you would never see 500 whp for 5k unless you bought really crappy parts, or bought them used.

Built several of them, never had an issue. Inline pro!=crappy parts

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 02:30 PM

With my particular car, 5 grand just won't happen. That's like a greddy turbo kit. Those things SUCK - I would never run another greddy kit, no matter how good they are on other cars. Crappy quality, manifolds crack constantly, etc. My particular kit, with a tubular manifold, good injectors, quality piping, etc, is $7500. You can find a good kit used for 5k, but I don't do used when it comes to parts like this.

Trust me, I know :) If I could've boosted my car for 5k and gotten the same results, I would have. It's just not feasible. The best you can do is piece together your own kit with some lower end parts and a nice garrett turbo and hit about 350-400 whp, but that's running a log mani, and that's a no-go for me.

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 02:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408548)
With my particular car, 5 grand just won't happen. That's like a greddy turbo kit. Those things SUCK - I would never run another greddy kit, no matter how good they are on other cars. Crappy quality, manifolds crack constantly, etc. My particular kit, with a tubular manifold, good injectors, quality piping, etc, is $7500. You can find a good kit used for 5k, but I don't do used when it comes to parts like this.

Trust me, I know :) If I could've boosted my car for 5k and gotten the same results, I would have. It's just not feasible. The best you can do is piece together your own kit with some lower end parts and a nice garrett turbo and hit about 350-400 whp, but that's running a log mani, and that's a no-go for me.

I think I know what I'm talking about on boosting Hondas.


I'm guessing you (overpaid for) got the swift kit. The stuff we put together is just as clean and runs about $5000-5500 with a 5857jb

Cambinese 11-15-2011 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by corbin09 (Post 1408475)
Mike- How much would it cost to replace the syncros on a 6mt with something stronger?

I have the same question.

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 03:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Red__Zed (Post 1408557)
I think I know what I'm talking about on boosting Hondas.


I'm guessing you (overpaid for) got the swift kit. The stuff we put together is just as clean and runs about $5000-5500 with a 5857jb

Does that $5500 include a full 3" exhaust, a 3" downpipe, tial bov/precision WG, AEM gauges, gauge holder, stage 4 clutch, $700 engine management, a full tune, 1000 CC injectors, a bigger fuel pump, a boost control solenoid, etc? Yeah, that's what I thought, :gtfo2:

If you factor out the engine management/tune, exhaust, gauges, clutch, injectors/fuel pump, etc, the core kit was only <$4500. That's about as cheap as you're going to get a fully hand-made kit. Look how much the greddy TT kit costs for this car? It's all mass-produced cast manifold garbage, and it's 8+ grand if I'm not mistaken. The kit I got is the cheapest "nice" kit you can get for my car before you step down to greddy junk. The cheapest quote I got from a reputable shop (Full Blown Motorsports) was $4500 for the kit, and that was literally just the piping they fabricated and the turbo, so easily add on $2000 or more for the rest of it. A full race kit is probably $2000 more than what I paid total as well. If you want to argue that FR is a waste of money and whatnot, then I donno what to tell ya, but we aren't speaking the same language.

Anyways, I'm not here to argue over Civic kits. I have zero doubt in my mind that I know more than you do about my specific car and turbo'ing it, so we'll end it here. If you think $7500 to completely turbo a Civic SI sedan with quality parts is outrageous, then whatevs. I'm here to learn about turbo'ing a 370 now, I've already conquered the SI for what I wanted. :)

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 04:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408788)
Does that $5500 include a full 3" exhaust, a 3" downpipe, tial bov/precision WG, AEM gauges, gauge holder, stage 4 clutch, $700 engine management, a full tune, 1000 CC injectors, a bigger fuel pump, a boost control solenoid, etc? Yeah, that's what I thought, :gtfo2:

)

Everything but the clutch. ;)

Even better, the guys I built for are still running the cars (last build was in 09), and not selling it 4 months after building it.



On the z trans, there is a lot of debate and not much data from hard use. You are probably good up to about the same limits as the stock bottom end.

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408788)

. I have zero doubt in my mind that I know more than you do about my specific car and turbo'ing it, so we'll end it here. :)

Did you ever get your car running? What did you dyno?

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 04:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Red__Zed (Post 1408809)
Everything but the clutch. ;)

Even better, the guys I built for are still running the cars (last build was in 09), and not selling it 4 months after building it.



On the z trans, there is a lot of debate and not much data from hard use. You are probably good up to about the same limits as the stock bottom end.

Honestly, I doubt that.. but if it's true, go over to 8thcivic.com and become a vendor, because you would be undercutting the next closest kit producer by almost 2 grand.

Yes, my car runs, I drive it every day. And no, I don't have a dyno graph as my tuner never gave me one, but I don't need one.. I already know what the kit is capable of, and I already know I'm running it near the fuel limits allowable. I'm not sure why you seem to find this so unbelievable - I run a pretty normal turbo setup. A turbo of this size running ~11 psi tends to put out around 450 whp. There is nothing magical or special about my build.

And as for your insinuation, the kit I bought has zero to do with me selling the car a few months after building it. It comes down to the sole fact that I built this car when my income was nill, and now I have a lot more coming in. Is it not the natural progression of a car enthusiast to move up to bigger and better things? I could sink $100,000 into my civic, but it'll never be a good platform. Hence the Z coming into play..

theDreamer 11-15-2011 04:35 PM

:wtf2:

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 04:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408880)
Honestly, I doubt that.. but if it's true, go over to 8thcivic.com and become a vendor, because you would be undercutting the next closest kit producer by almost 2 grand.


Built quite a few kits for friends, not interested in doing it full time. For it to financially make sense, I'm wanting 25%+ margins, looking at similar prices to the vendors....Then add on dealing with a Honda crew that brings way too much liability....no thanks.

Quote:

Yes, my car runs, I drive it every day. And no, I don't have a dyno graph as my tuner never gave me one, but I don't need one.. I already know what the kit is capable of, and I already know I'm running it near the fuel limits allowable. I'm not sure why you seem to find this so unbelievable - I run a pretty normal turbo setup. A turbo of this size running ~11 psi tends to put out around 450 whp. There is nothing magical or special about my build.
I've never know a tuner to not produce dynos.

Nothing special or magical about it, just weird to not have them.


Quote:


And as for your insinuation, the kit I bought has zero to do with me selling the car a few months after building it. It comes down to the sole fact that I built this car when my income was nill, and now I have a lot more coming in. Is it not the natural progression of a car enthusiast to move up to bigger and better things? I could sink $100,000 into my civic, but it'll never be a good platform. Hence the Z coming into play..
Your shop seems to think your car had/still has all sorts of problems.



Anyways, best of luck with the z. The switch to rwd should be fun. Make sure to invest in real tires though.

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 04:55 PM

I think you have me mistaken with someone else. I've literally had one single problem since turbo'ing my car (mechinically), and that was just me needing to replace the IC clamps with better ones since I developed a slight boost leak. Other than that, it has been rock solid. My only other issues have been putting the power to the ground, which is why I've begun to sour on the platform.

Red__Zed 11-15-2011 04:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by awkwardturtle (Post 1408935)
I think you have me mistaken with someone else. I've literally had one single problem since turbo'ing my car (mechinically), and that was just me needing to replace the IC clamps with better ones since I developed a slight boost leak. Other than that, it has been rock solid. My only other issues have been putting the power to the ground, which is why I've begun to sour on the platform.

"I vtec, do you?"

blackonorange 11-15-2011 05:16 PM

Lolololol nothing beats vtec

awkwardturtle 11-15-2011 05:17 PM

Yes sir. What shop are you talking about? I had a small shop do my install, and I haven't communicated with the installer much since except to tell him how happy I was with the work he did. If you even look through my build thread, you'll notice the only frustration I ran into was why my tune was being all wonky, and that turned out to be because of a leaking clamp.

m4a1mustang 11-15-2011 05:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Red__Zed (Post 1408936)
"I vtec, do you?"

Dude what experience do you have with big power hondas? None. Leave the kid alone.

:|


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:12 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2