Nissan 370Z Forum

Nissan 370Z Forum (http://www.the370z.com/)
-   Engine & Drivetrain (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/)
-   -   Dirty gritty drained oil when I did the oil change today (http://www.the370z.com/engine-drivetrain/15818-dirty-gritty-drained-oil-when-i-did-oil-change-today.html)

LaSeeno 03-17-2010 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 450890)
Soooo....my buddy (who used to be a mechanic) said that it sounds like my value guide(s) could be worn, which would explain the copperish color shavings in the oil, the oil consumption, and the valuetrain noise that I had prior to the oil change a few weeks ago.

We'll see....only time will tell. I'll keep ya'll updated.

I think he said "valve" guides.

In any case... None of what you're experiencing should happen on a new vehicle.

semtex 03-17-2010 03:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by j.arnaldo (Post 450901)
I'll tell you a brief story I read in this forum: An engineer from the U.S. went thru' the trouble of purchasing a sample of each brand of oil filter on the market; he proceeded to "disect" (i.e. cut in ˝, and inspect) each and everyone of 'em: His conclusion was that Pureone by Purolator is THE best oil filter available to us on the market. Remember: I'm not an engineer. This is the conclusion a pro' in his field arrived at. Since I've been using that brand, my engine oil comes out less nasty than it used to, 'cause the filtering element is of superior quality, according to this guy. Give it a shot, dude!

I don't think he's having a filtration issue. Just sayin'

dlmartin81 03-17-2010 03:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LaSeeno (Post 451011)
I think he said "valve" guides.

In any case... None of what you're experiencing should happen on a new vehicle.

:rofl2: Yeah, I meant valve, not value.

But yes, I agree. Which is why I find it ridiculous. Perhaps I bought a lemon, as they call it.

dlmartin81 03-17-2010 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex (Post 451085)
I don't think he's having a filtration issue. Just sayin'

Yes, definitely not filtration.

dlmartin81 03-17-2010 05:15 PM

Well, it turns out that the oil light that I got earlier today was from my preset oil change reminder, NOT low oil.....lol.:facepalm: I got in the car again after work and the damn light was still on. I'm like, "How is that possible? I topped off at lunch." I looked under the car and didn't see any oil on the ground.

See, I did my oil change a few hundred miles before the reminder and completely forget to reset it.

However, the oil level was a little low, so I added about .5 quart. Which still indicates to me that it may be consuming more oil than it should BUT at least it's not as drastic as I thought.

ZForce 03-17-2010 11:16 PM

1/2 qrt in how many miles?

SoCal 370Z 03-17-2010 11:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZForce (Post 452075)
1/2 qrt in how many miles?

^^^Ditto

AK370Z 03-18-2010 12:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 450782)

I went out for lunch today and my oil light came on. I checked the dipstick and it was definitely low. So I stopped at Pep Boys and got some Mobile1 to top it off. I'm gonna start carrying the Red Line in the car for now on until this issue is resolved.

dl, that's not recommended. You really shouldn't mix oil from two different groups. This guy on ebay (who's store is in PA, same state as you) ships really fast. From placing order to my doorstep (i'm in NJ) - always less than 48 hours. Since you're in same state, it'll probably be quicker. Buy a quart or two just to be safe.

Good luck with the whole thing man! I don't know what happen. Everything was going so well and then this :(. If you need anything, let me know.

SoCal 370Z 03-18-2010 12:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AK370Z (Post 452104)
dl, that's not recommended. You really shouldn't mix oil from two different groups. This guy on ebay (who's store is in PA, same state as you) ships really fast. From placing order to my doorstep (i'm in NJ) - always less than 48 hours. Since you're in same state, it'll probably be quicker. Buy a quart or two just to be safe.

Napa typically sells Redline too.

dlmartin81 03-18-2010 08:00 AM

Mmmm....I put about 600-700 miles on the new oil.

The reason I bought Mobile1 is because I thought I really had a problem. Again, that oil light that came on (which turned out to be the the damn reminder) got me scared that I was running bone dry and afraid that I wouldn't make it home. I live about 30 some miles from work. So I needed something in the interim. Desperate times....desperate measures.

I have extra RL oil at home and is now in my car.

semtex 03-18-2010 10:22 AM

You're checking your oil level when your engine's cold, right? (Or at least give it 20-30 mins after turning off so that the oil drains into the pan.) If you check your oil when your engine is hot, it may read artificially low on the dipstick because all the oil has yet to drain back into the oil pan. So then you go and add oil, and presto. You just overfilled.

dlmartin81 03-18-2010 10:36 AM

^^ Yeah, I know to wait some time. I was in Pep Boys for about 15 mins before going to the car and reading the dipstick and adding more.

ZForce 03-19-2010 01:37 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 452376)
…...I put about 600-700 miles on the new oil………..


With that kind of oil consumption… ˝ qrt or more within 600 miles on the current OCI, then I would suggest:

Get your oil sample sent out with lab you have chosen to go with; dyson or blackstone.
Check the oil when the engine is cold (sat over night).
If you are indeed consuming ˝ qrt within the next 600 miles.

Then:

1) Get the car to the dealer and request that an oil consumption test be started. Make sure you have them document on the service order “customer states engine is consuming excessive amounts of oil”. Be sure you are present when they take the dipstick reading and that they let the car sit on a level surface for 20 minutes before taking the reading. They may want to change the oil and they might want to (it varies between dealers) tie off the drain bolt and filler cap during the test.

2) Talk to your service mgr and let him know you will be contacting NNA to open a case on excessive oil consumption. If you got a lemon, the sooner you report it to NNA the better for a case later on depending on the Lemon Law for your state of residence. By all means treat the service mgr well and do not piss him off because it will be his call when NNA contacts him on a recommendation to replace the engine or not.

This is just a heads up, if you find yourself going down that road, hopefully not though. I have been there and done that with the bro's 06 Z33 6MT and it’s not a fun experience.

phantom21 03-19-2010 05:32 AM

Are those metal shavings or air bubbles coming out? First pic looks like shavings, second angle looks more like air bubbles. I would lean more toward water contamination. I just did my first RL change at about 3600 miles on it and the oil did have a different hue to it than normal dyno or Nissan Ester oil, but not as milky as yours was...no flakes or grit. IF its not flakes, hope its water bubbles. I would get some temp up in the motor and drain the oil. Then get that oil analyzed.

dlmartin81 03-19-2010 11:19 AM

FuszNissan -- Could you have one of your service department guys to take a look at these pics (1st page) and get their opinion?

dlmartin81 03-19-2010 11:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ZForce (Post 454105)
With that kind of oil consumption… ˝ qrt or more within 600 miles on the current OCI, then I would suggest:

Get your oil sample sent out with lab you have chosen to go with; dyson or blackstone.
Check the oil when the engine is cold (sat over night).
If you are indeed consuming ˝ qrt within the next 600 miles.

Then:

1) Get the car to the dealer and request that an oil consumption test be started. Make sure you have them document on the service order “customer states engine is consuming excessive amounts of oil”. Be sure you are present when they take the dipstick reading and that they let the car sit on a level surface for 20 minutes before taking the reading. They may want to change the oil and they might want to (it varies between dealers) tie off the drain bolt and filler cap during the test.

2) Talk to your service mgr and let him know you will be contacting NNA to open a case on excessive oil consumption. If you got a lemon, the sooner you report it to NNA the better for a case later on depending on the Lemon Law for your state of residence. By all means treat the service mgr well and do not piss him off because it will be his call when NNA contacts him on a recommendation to replace the engine or not.

This is just a heads up, if you find yourself going down that road, hopefully not though. I have been there and done that with the bro's 06 Z33 6MT and it’s not a fun experience.

Thanks for the advice.

I checked the oil level this morning before going to work and it was about 3/4 from the low to high marker on the dipstick. And my driveway is pretty level. I know Semtex had a concern that I may have misread it and overfilled the other day. That wasn't the case. It really did loss oil.

Quote:

Originally Posted by phantom21 (Post 454173)
Are those metal shavings or air bubbles coming out? First pic looks like shavings, second angle looks more like air bubbles. I would lean more toward water contamination. I just did my first RL change at about 3600 miles on it and the oil did have a different hue to it than normal dyno or Nissan Ester oil, but not as milky as yours was...no flakes or grit. IF its not flakes, hope its water bubbles. I would get some temp up in the motor and drain the oil. Then get that oil analyzed.

The oil was definitely gritty and those copper looking specs where not bubbles.

I have already requested a testing kit from BlackStone. I'm still waiting on its arrival.

kannibul 03-19-2010 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 454543)

I have already requested a testing kit from BlackStone. I'm still waiting on its arrival.

Did you take that oil and put it in a clean container? If not, then its contaminated.

Otherwise, I guess you could drain some out from what you have in the pan, and note the amount of oil you added on the form.

dlmartin81 03-19-2010 02:16 PM

The old oil is contaminated, yes. I did two oil changes in one afternoon, mine and my wife's, and mine was last; otherwise, I would have kept it aside.

When I receive the testing kit, I plan to drain whatever is needed and then top it back off.

gumpy 03-20-2010 08:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 454728)
The old oil is contaminated, yes. I did two oil changes in one afternoon, mine and my wife's, and mine was last; otherwise, I would have kept it aside.

When I receive the testing kit, I plan to drain whatever is needed and then top it back off.

Even if it is comtaminated isn't it worth getting at analysed? they could at least tell you about the presence of certain metals right... and you can be 90% sure it's from the z... From the picture if that orange stuff is metal then your readings are going to be off the chart...

really hope there's nothing wrong with your engine, hope it is just a bit of water like the others have metioned...

dlmartin81 03-20-2010 11:17 AM

Yeah...I hope so too.

But to be honest, I don't know what I should do first. Too many options...too many paths to take. I've thought about sending the contaminated oil like you said, but I want to get an accurate report of my oil and my engine's 'wear'/'oil consumption' so I can take to the dealer as proof. Yes, I could get two analysis done but that would mean extra time (because I'd have to order another testing kit) and I don't want to spend more time on the road than I have to. I would have taken the car to the dealer by now but I'm waiting for the testing....so I can have proof.

j.arnaldo 03-20-2010 11:50 AM

Considering the fact that the oil filter element's the core an oil filter, it figures that the better the filtering element is, the less contaminated the oil's gonna come out at oil-change time. But, I'm the first the admit that I'm neither an engineer nor a mechanic, so just ignore my logical conclusion, which may not have too much logic at all due to my lack of expertise on these issues. Mostly, I depend on guys like you and your experiences and related searches.

kannibul 03-20-2010 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by j.arnaldo (Post 455746)
Considering the fact that the oil filter element's the core an oil filter, it figures that the better the filtering element is, the less contaminated the oil's gonna come out at oil-change time. But, I'm the first the admit that I'm neither an engineer nor a mechanic, so just ignore my logical conclusion, which may not have too much logic at all due to my lack of expertise on these issues. Mostly, I depend on guys like you and your experiences and related searches.

The particles that drained out the pan were too heavy to get picked up and filtered.

I imagine when he drains it again for the test, he should get some more, as draining it once likely didn't get it all.

j.arnaldo 03-20-2010 12:47 PM

Now THAT sounds serious. I hadn't picked that part up. Nasty situation. If the Z's under warranty, he needs to go to the dealership ASAP.

dlmartin81 03-20-2010 10:11 PM

^^ Will do....as soon as I get my oil analysis done. The kit has still to arrive at my doorstep.

IDZRVIT 03-21-2010 08:32 AM

Have you considered getting an oil filter debris analysis? Maybe BS does this?

j.arnaldo 03-21-2010 12:03 PM

Hey!, How 'bout one of those AMWAY Super-duper oil filtration systems?! I've heard they're great--though expensive. Do a search on that, man.

IDZRVIT 03-21-2010 02:11 PM

IMHO, oil filtration is far more important than oil type. Those mag filter covers are only good for collecting the magnetic particles. So where are the other non-magnetic particles going? Hence, if you require better filtration, maybe an investment in a better oil filtration system is in order as j.arnaldo suggests. Someone can correct me but I believe a standard filter will not pass particles less than 30 microns. Particles less than 30 microns that do pass are most likely not a show stopper for your engine. They will either get embedded in the bearing babbitt, eventually settle in the base pan or other places where sludge forms.

semtex 03-21-2010 04:43 PM

LOL. I just noticed the tag on this thread.

Re. filtration, I've said it before -- I don't think filtration is the issue. The issue is that those particles shouldn't be there to need filtering to begin with!

Modshack 03-21-2010 04:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex (Post 457661)
LOL. I just noticed the tag on this thread.

Re. filtration, I've said it before -- I don't think filtration is the issue. The issue is that those particles shouldn't be there to need filtering to begin with!

:iagree:...Filtration is not the problem here..

IDZRVIT 03-21-2010 06:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by semtex (Post 457661)
LOL. I just noticed the tag on this thread.

Re. filtration, I've said it before -- I don't think filtration is the issue. The issue is that those particles shouldn't be there to need filtering to begin with!

Obviously, filtration is not the issue. The OP has a wear issue and changing the oil won't fix it.

dlmartin81 03-22-2010 08:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IDZRVIT (Post 457040)
Have you considered getting an oil filter debris analysis? Maybe BS does this?

I mistakenly through it away. I did two oil changes in one afternoon (mine and my wife's) and threw everything (except the oil) into a bag and into the trash.

370Zsteve 03-22-2010 08:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by blackflag (Post 437920)
I have to say...I'm not a fan of the longer oil change intervals that everybody is pushing these days. It may be good for the environment, and good for the car companies' marketing...but it's not good for an engine.

Agreed. Also, you do know that oil is recycled these days, right?

370Zsteve 03-22-2010 08:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 432820)
So yesterday (3/6) was my first time swapping out old RL oil. It was also my first time with an oil containing ester. So as I was draining the oil, I noticed some unusual properties. 1) The oil color was milk chocolate like, mixed with some copper. RL does have a golden-amber color out of the quart. So I guess this is normal. Is it?? 2) The oil was kind of gritty. My engine has roughly 9.3K miles on it...still pretty new. Could the grittiness be because it's still in a break-in phase and those are the metal remains. Or perhaps this is normal. I probably never noticed it with other oils because of the color. Typically, all other oils were pitch black when I swapped them. RL color perhaps makes it more noticeable.

Below are some pics to help explain what I saw. Please tell me this is normal.

That looks like oil from a 1970 chevy that hasn't been changed in 5 years, wtf??? Any white smoke coming out of your tailpipe? Blown head gasket? WTF??????!

370Zsteve 03-22-2010 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by j.arnaldo (Post 457196)
Hey!, How 'bout one of those AMWAY Super-duper oil filtration systems?! I've heard they're great--though expensive. Do a search on that, man.

You mean Amsoil? please tell me you meant Amsoil. :icon14:

370Zsteve 03-22-2010 09:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by dlmartin81 (Post 455687)
Yeah...I hope so too.

But to be honest, I don't know what I should do first. Too many options...too many paths to take. I've thought about sending the contaminated oil like you said, but I want to get an accurate report of my oil and my engine's 'wear'/'oil consumption' so I can take to the dealer as proof. Yes, I could get two analysis done but that would mean extra time (because I'd have to order another testing kit) and I don't want to spend more time on the road than I have to. I would have taken the car to the dealer by now but I'm waiting for the testing....so I can have proof.

I thought you mixed your oil with your wife's car's oil? If so, dump the analysis idea.

semtex 03-22-2010 09:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370Zsteve (Post 458482)
You mean Amsoil? please tell me you meant Amsoil. :icon14:

Amway, Amsoil, what's the diff? :stirthepot: (I kid, I kid.)

dlmartin81 03-22-2010 10:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370Zsteve (Post 458481)
That looks like oil from a 1970 chevy that hasn't been changed in 5 years, wtf??? Any white smoke coming out of your tailpipe? Blown head gasket? WTF??????!

I haven't noticed any white smoke; however, I have noticed a slight smell coming from the vents when I use the A/C or heat. It could be my imagination...I don't know.

Quote:

Originally Posted by 370Zsteve (Post 458484)
I thought you mixed your oil with your wife's car's oil? If so, dump the analysis idea.

Well, I am planning to drain (whatever is needed) some oil and send it for testing. I called BlackStone and they said that they like oil to have at least 1K miles of use before testing. So once I get the testing kit (hopefully this week) and once I've driven over 1K with the new oil, I'll drain some, send it, and wait for the results.

The idea is, if I have a serious problem, then there should be some evidence of it in the current (new) oil.

LiquidZ 03-22-2010 01:14 PM

You guys are ruthless haha.

j.arnaldo 03-22-2010 02:00 PM

Amsoil products are a subsidiary/offshoot of the AMWAY corp.--if I'm not mistaken. I could be wrong, but AMWAY reps down here distribute Amsoil, too.

LiquidZ 03-22-2010 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by j.arnaldo (Post 458941)
Amsoil products are a subsidiary/offshoot of the AMWAY corp.--if I'm not mistaken. I could be wrong, but AMWAY reps down here distribute Amsoil, too.

Honestly, I have never heard of Amway. Browsing their products, I don't see any mention of Amsoil whatsoever. Plus, on my way to becoming T-1 certified, I never encountered Amway along the way. It appears they utilize the same marketing strategy, which might be a source of confusion. Lastly, anybody can become a dealer if they wanted.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:14 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2